Exagger-eyes Volumizing and Curling Mascara

Doesn’t smudge

This is a thick mascara that coats very well. I always wipe my wand before use as it can go on to thick if you don’t know how to use mascara like this. I loved it because it made my Lashes long and thick and it didn’t flake or run all night long

Does all it says it won't do

Save your money. I'm happy I had a free trial size to try because this mascara clumped, flaked, and did not last even for a few hours. I wear contact lenses and I'm always looking for a long lasting mascara that will allow me to take my contacts in and out if I happen to get something in my eye. This mascara is not it.

Sadly not good at all

I love CT products but this mascara is awful. I was so disappointed. It doesn't lift, volumize or curl at all. It's super heavy and clumpy and gets everywhere. It's SO messy and thick and doesn't do anything but make a huge mess.

I love mascara

Mascara is my favorite makeup to buy! This one is perfect, my lashes get volume and length with this one!

Upsetting

first of all this mascara is pretty expensive and I had high hopes for it from reading the reviews and looking at the product photos. However, the product did not at all do what is advertized and thats so unfortunate. I was so excited but it didnt work out. The mascara did not coat my eyelashes very well and it made my eyelashes look so sparce. No volume and especially no curl. If you want a mascara that holds a curl and has actual volume to it, dont buy this, id recommend too faced better...

Excellent product

Hello, I really liked your mascara. It lengthens the lashes—it's truly amazing.

Really clumpy not what was expected, was told it was perfect for volume but it wasnt :(

This mascara is AMAZING- LOVE LOVE LOVE!

I bought this on a whim and was SHOCKED at how good it is. It is the perfect texture not too wet or dry. I love multiple coats of mascara and it allows for that without clumping or flaking. It separates, curls and lengthens.!it literally gives the perfect lash. The packaging is luxurious being a glass container and this lovely lock closure. I fully expected this would be meh and it is fabulous. I absolutely love it.

Feels thick and heavy

This applies very wet and heavy onto my Asian lashes. I curled before applying, and after applying it started immediately to lose curl and flatten down. Very thick formula would not recommend for Asian lashes.

Flaky

So flaky. Was all over my undereye within 5 hours.

Solid mascara

This is currently my favorite mascara. It gives lots of volume right away, you dont need to build on multiple layers. I also feel like it let's my lashes hold a curl pretty well and doesn't flake all over before the end of the day.

I’ve repurchased a few times now. I have tried others but I keep going back to this one. Love the buildable volume and it holds my curl all day. Gives some length but more volume. No spider lashes. Lasts all day on me even wearing contact lenses.

Returning!

I alresy have long eyelashes but I wanted to enhance them a little more but unfortunately it left my eyelashes clumpy and was hard to remove with makeup remover wipes.

Disappointed

I bought this mascara last week and unfortunately it makes my lashes fall flat. I curl my lashes before applying it, but the curl doesn’t last once I put on the mascara. I really wanted to love it, but it doesn’t work for my lashes.

EXAGGER-EYES

THE BEST MASCARA I'VE EVER USED. THE NAME OF THE MASCARA FITS THE DESCRIPTION PERFECTLY! IT DOES EXACTLY THAT!

Clumpy

Purchased the travel size to try it out, but its awful. Eyelashes clump!! I will be returning this mascara.

Very nice, natural look

I may purchase a larger size on my next visit. I am comparing two products to determine the best look for me.

Wow!!! 🤯 One of the best…

Love this masacara it makes my eyelashes look amazing. Is so intense and durable. Happy I found it.

Long lasting volume

Im in love with this mascara it gives what it needs to give. My new favorite ❤️

THIS is a MUST HAVE mascara!

Best mascara ever! Holds an amazing curl, adds volume and also really lengthens my lashes. No flakes and it gives such a dramatic lash effect. I always get compliments wearing this mascara!

This is one of the worst mascaras that I have ever used. It's compareable to any other mascara but it smudges to foundation.

not clumpy, nice formula but no hold

goes on beautifully, doesn't clump at all and easy to apply. you do need a few coats for that volume. only drawback is that it has no hold whatsoever. if you don't mind that then this is a great mascara. I got it with my points/offers so I didn't have to buy one. for me personally I prefer the diorshow overvolume waterproof mascara (hasn't been out long), I need the waterproof since I work with humidity and moisture

Every mascara I've ever tried has always left me with panda eyes or flakes. This is the only mascara that actually meets most of my goals. The only reason why I didn't give 5 stars is 1 because it's pretty pricey, 2 because I CANT STOP BUYING IT ITS SO GOOD

Not worth it

I got this on sale and i would have returned it but i threw out the box. Dont waste your money, it clumps so bad. My $7 maybelline lash sensational mascara is 100xs better than this one. Hard pass.

Lashes

Love the way this mascara lights on magnifies your Lashes and feels lightweight

Had high hopes:(

I'm a big fan of almost all Charlotte Tilbury products, so was really excited to try this. Sadly, I'm returning it today, as it did not live up to my high hopes. I found it to be very clumpy—made my lashes stick together. I also found that it flaked quite a bit once dry. While the tube itself is very pretty and feels substantial, it's actually quite heavy/bulky which isn't great for carrying around in your purse. Going back to my staple mascara—Better Than Sex. It's pretty tough to beat!

I was not impressed. Would not buy again

Did nothing more than my 10 dollar Coverr Girlb mascara does

Terrible

Terrible mascara. It makes your lashes stick together. Makes them look like you didn't wash off yesterday's mascaras. Throughout day, at work I had to go to the bathroom to remove it. It would keep crumbling and getting in my eyes.

Expensive and drys out fast.

This product started drying out within the first couple of days for the price,I expected to stay wet longer and to go on without clumping. This started happening in the first couple of days , which is really disappointing.

Not a winner

I kept wanting to love this stuff but it wasn’t good especially for the price.. flaked off after a little while and left me with “panda eyes”. Then ironically it was hard to get off with my typical nightly routine. I wouldn’t recommend this product. I’ll stick with Lancôme.

Great mascara

I purchased this when it was half off about two months ago. The trick is to let it sit in the tube for a while after opening, that way it thickens and isn’t as runny. I find that it adds beautiful volume to my lashes

Too wet & takes too much work

The formula feels very wet and takes a long time to dry, which made my lashes look weighed down instead of lifted. I also had to apply multiple coats just to get a noticeable result. Unfortunately, it ended up being more work than I expected and didn’t give me the look I was hoping for.

AMAZING

I absolutely love this mascara. It's my New ride or die!

Love this mascara

I've tried so many mascara's but keep coming back to this one. I have sensitive eyes and never had an issue.

Not happy

I love Charlotte tilbery but this mascara is very clumpy my eyelashes stick together and looks bad

Non recommandé

Over rated, j’aime vraiment pas aucun effet sur moi

100% Worth The Buy!

I absolutely LOVE this product! It is a big staple in my everyday lash routine making my lashes stand out! This is one of the best mascaras I have ever purchased! This is 100% being re-purchased! 

Is a no from me

So slippery it kept coming right off of my lashes. Had zero hold. Had to return. 

Soooo BAD

It clumps, it flakes, it doesn't make lashes look thicker. DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY!

A must have in my daily routine!

After using this product for several weeks I have finally found a mascara that is perfect for my lashes.

Disappointed

This mascara didn't perform at all. I really liked CT's Pillow Talk mascara so I was extra disappointed. This formula made my lashes super clumpy and they somehow looked shorter (!!). Honestly, you can find better at the drugstore. I only gave it 2 stars because I liked the wand.

Everyday mascara that hardly flakes

My all-time favorite mascara that hardly flakes! It's the only one I’ve tried—despite trying many—that doesn’t flake or smudge. Absolutely worth it!

Horrible mascara

Got this during the 50% off sale & I should of tried earlier cause now I can’t return and it sucks it chunky and formula is either old or just bad

Eye look great

They really make my eyelashes look beautiful

Stay Away

This product was recommended by 2 Sephora employees (they were pushing it hard, not sure the reasoning on that) but I actually hate it so much! It is SO clumpy and gives instant spider lashes. Even after trying to comb them out, they were clumpy and awful looking.

Have bought it a number of times

Does not flake & is water proof

It's okay

I do like it but honestly it doesn't perform any better than any other mascara I've used. I don't think I would be able to tell if I used this vs a drugstore brand mascara, and for that reason I don't think I'd purchase again. I wanted to love it.

Flaky fall outs everywhere

Nothing special, need to apply a lot of coats for lengthening effect but the worst is the flaky fall overs all day round. Everyone keeps telling me there are little black dust around me cheek area falling from the dried down mascara, and this happened even on days I only applied 2 coats. Returning this.

Won't buy again

What worked when I was younger doesn't anymore. I am always trying mascaras. This one clumped and flaked on me.

Worth it

After a few years of searching, trying high end to low end mascaras....I bought this on 21 days of beauty and I'm in love. Wish I would have bought 3-4 while on sale!

No I would not buy this

The mascara left my eyelashes looking very clumpy. Too expensive for having to throw it out

Immediate Return

The only good thing about this mascara is how dark it is. Other than that it's a clumpy mess that dries weirdly. You can only do one coat because it dries so quickly and weirdly.

Clumpy and had fallout

So clumpy even after brushing through with a clean spoolie. After about 4 hrs I had mascara fallout under my eyes

Def going to be a repurchase

Loved this mascara, goes on easy and looks great

I would buy again

I like it a lot. The brush is not rough like some mascaras. It doesn't smudge. Would like the lashes to look a little fuller.

No.

This is why I hardly ever pivot from my go to. This was honestly, probably one of the worst mascaras I have ever used. SO so flaky. I had high hopes after seeing all of the positive reviews. Won't buy again.

Would not buy!

Made my lashes look short and clumpy! Sticking to drugstore!

The packaging and everything was so beautiful I had really high hopes for it. Just isn’t for me. I returned it.

Definitely I would buy again

Great mascara

If you have sensitive or watery eyes this is it!

Finally found a mascara that doesn’t irritate my eyes, break my lashes off, flake or clump ..in this pic i have no eye makeup on other than a couple light layers of this CT mascara fyi i did buy this half off on sale i would typically never spend $30 on mascara but i may have to start buying this one bc so far its the only one that works for me

No clumping great for sensitive eyes

I rarely find a mascara thst doesnt clump ,flake ,irritate my sensitive eyes or turn to hard stiff lashes causing me to lose lashes when removing! This is so natural yet can be built up . I think it adds great length and a natural volume

The worst

This is probably the worst prestigious branded mascara I have ever bought. Brand new tube is clumpy and flaky. I was in the mind set it might be a old tube so I bought another one. Nope it's just the product. Id avoid this mascara like the plague.

Clump

A clumpy mess, makes my lashes look short.

not worth the hype

made my lashes fall flat and gave them noo volume or length at all. sticking to my maybeline😵‍💫

I really like this product

I bought this during the 21 days of beauty and I have really liked this product. My only complaint is that it is very wet and takes a while to dry on my eyelashes. The product does what it says it will and has made my lashes look gorgeous. It also comes off very easily when I want it to. I would definitely purchase this product again.

Love it. Natural look.

I'm on my second tube of this mascara and I love it. Seems gentle on the lashes, great natural look, I get compliments every day lol. Not the funnest to take off but I've had worse. Once in a while I try one and no one comments on my lashes so I go back to this one lol. I don't even wear an eye liner anymore.

One of my new favs

I have always bought drugstore mascaras, but during the 21 days of beauty sale I bought this! I am now obsessed. It isn't waterproof but it also doesnt budge on my oily eyes. I love this!!!

BAD!!

I have purchased many mascaras over the years, both drugstore and high end, and this has got to be the absolute worst! It’s super clumpy and heavy and gives serious raccoon eyes. To make everything worse, I thought this was tubing or something because it t burns and irritates my eyes so bad. Like I have grains of salt in my eyes. Do not recommend.

Sticking to Clinique

I thought I would give this a try since it was on sale. The first coat made my lashes stick straight out. I applied a couple more and just got a gloppy mess. My usual Clinique mascara curls and gives volume from the get go. Definitely didn't see the results anyone else is getting.

Don’t buy

The formula reminds me of a cheap drug store brand. I would not recommend paying $30 for this when you can have the same results from a drug store brand for $8.

worth your money

my new favorite mascara, sticking to this one for now on, it does exactly what it says, PLUS! my eyelashes did not feel heavy, and I did several coats, looooved the glass bottle...

Wow, what a great mascara

This actually is good mascara. I am a loyal fan of Lancome Defincils Mascara, as it always adds dramatic length! The Charlotte Tilbury mascara adds volume and length on my already long lashes. What a difference a mascara will make! It gives me more volume and length with two coats. Although you have to go from root to tip in one stroke to avoid any clumping! I would definitely purchase this mascara!

I love this mascara for so many reasons. Firstly, I have very sensitive eyes and skin, as well as I wear contacts. This mascara does not cause any irritation and it does not stick to my contact lenses. Most importantly, it stays on and looks good through hours of tears. I know because my boyfriend and I almost ended things yesterday and I cried for almost 8 hours. The mascara did not run and it did not budge off of my eyelashes. I still looked like a baddie even though I was falling apart....

WORTH IT, get it !

I am in love with this mascara. After months of hesitation to buy this, d/t price and availability nearby (not counting online), I convinced myself to get the full size after trying a sample, and fell in love. I figured I was buying the name when I saw the price online, but oh was I wrong. This mascara, is so smooth to apply, and I don't care much for this type bristle applicator, but it HAS NOT failed to deliver-no clumping together of bristles when product is on it, not disfigured by...

Charlotte Tilbury has done it again

This mascara is truly amazing to start. I do have long lashes, but for my lashes to go up to my eyebrows, WOW game changer. I've alway used Lancome Definicil and have received so many compliments over the years on my lashes. I was given a trial size of this mascara and wow, I am so amazed… I also love that it comes in a glass bottle, I mean, just don't drop it on a tile bathroom floor. Since using this, I have been asked if I have on false lashes! Nope, just Charlotte Tilbury mascara. No...

Ridiculous

I wanted to like this so badly and gave it so many chances, but something about this formula and brush is just awful. It's goopy and no matter how I try to apply it it doesn't add volume, curl, or real length. It weighs lashes down and its just absurd for the price

Underwhelming

Very underwhelming results. I need about 10 coats to make it look like I am wearing mascara. Does not give much volume. I also don't like that Sephora seems to sell used products. The tube I got initially was half empty. I returned that only to find the same issue with the second one. Absolutely ridiculous.

absolute go to!

always my go to! it’s really good n lasts all day

Very meh

Like others say this isn’t great. Reminds me of volumiser mascara from pharmacy that I would buy 20 years ago at 4x the price. I went to buy my usual mascara and the employees insisted I buy this mascara as it’s “amazing” and way better than my other one. Well it’s not. As others mentioned it’s dry out of the box and seems stale. Wish I had stuck to my usual mascara

Terrible, flakey mess.

I am convinced that every positive review of this mascara was either a paid review, or that they were gifted it in exchange for a great review. This mascara is TERRIBLE. So flakey that I am afraid to not fully scrub it off after a few hours. It ends up all over my cheeks and in my eyes. The wand does not work with the thickness of it, (no product ever ends up on the inner curve of the wand) This felt like 5 year old mascara immediately upon opening. I could not return. It was a gift from a...

my new favorite mascara

This mascara is lengthening, volumizing, and curls your lashes. It doesn't clump and looks so pretty!!

I will be buying this again!

What a difference it makes to spend a little more on mascara. This is a beautiful, affordable, mascara that goes on so smoothly and lasts all day. It doesn't require a ton of applications & my lashes look great!

It goes on a little clumpy

I won't be buying again

Meh

It's ok. Nothing like the before and after pictures would indicate. Just a mascara.

Disappointing

This mascara is everything it says it’s not. It’s flakey, clumps and if you want to put on eyeliner after, forget about it!

Fantastic mascara!!

Fantastic mascara! Love this formula and it stays put while giving soft fluttery lashes. Would definitely recommend!

Flakey

Wanted to love this as it was recommended by a Sephora employee. It flaked so much I couldn’t wear it with contacts. My eyes were very irritated. And this was from when the product was new - it wasn’t old or dried out. Wouldn’t recommend for sensitive eyes or contact wearers.

Awesome Mascara

This great mascara gives you volume and the look of class. I was glad I found a mini size for on the go to purchase. Definitely would recommend and look forward to many more purchases of this to come. If you want that bold and volume type of look, this is a product for you!

Best mascara

Everything from Charlotte Tilbury is so good I swear. This is the best mescara I ever used in my life, I LOVE ITTT. Highly recomend!

must have

wow. this mascara adds incredible volume and length to my not so very long lashes. the darkness of the black makes my eyes pop. i highly recommend this for any lash type

Makes my lashes full.

I actually like this product, because it gives good volume to my eye lashes, nice.

A must have

Love this mascara, I have pretty straight lashes and this makes it hold a curl and I get SO MANY compliments when I wear it. I love it!!

Ehhhh

Don’t get me wrong, this is a beautiful mascara, lots of volume and drama…. For about 2 hours, then you will have raccoon eyes. For that price it should not transfer!!

Doesn’t stay on as well as I’d hoped

I should have just stuck to my Lancôme mascara, but I love CT products and wanted to try it. The saleswoman said it was smudge-proof and should hold up well in a tropical environment. It doesn’t smudge, but it flakes instead. I am a yoga teacher and this doesn’t work for me. Can only wear if I know I will not be sweating. Yes, it’s pretty good for curling and volume. Definitely not for definition

It’s nice but not for me.

I decided to try a different mascara from my usual one, thinking that this would provide better results. It really didn’t. It’s not bad, but I just wish it provided more lift and separation.

Had to buy another one.

This was the first time I had purchased this... and loved how it made my eyes look so much went out and purchased another one the next week

The first mascara İ purchased lasted me 4 months,and then I repurchased again,this time it was dry from beginning. Not worth the money.

Not worth the money at all

The best part about it is the packaging which is glass. Was fine for the first two days then got super clumpy. Don't waste your money.

Everything You Could Want!

I absolutely love this mascara! I was getting pretty frustrated with a lot of mascaras I was trying flaking off into my eyes… my husband literally calling it “lava-scara” because it would irritate so badly! But this one STAYS ON and comes off almost tune like! It’s amazing!

My new fav

Really like this. It is thicker and you have to work with it a little. I look bold lashes

Don't like trial size

I tried it and didn't get the results I was looking for and the cost was too high

Holy Grail Mascara

I received a sample with purchase and I was pleasantly surprised at how much I liked it. The volume and lengthing are insane! I had been using MAC Stack for years and was used to it not lasting through the day. This mascara not only lasts through the day but it also doesn't flake or irritate my eyes in any way. I highly recommend!

Finally a mascara that works for me

First mascara in a long time that gives me lift and curl without transferring on to my eyelids after a couple hours of wear

Love

One of my favorites for sure! Not clumping and creates nice long lashes

Clumpy & Heavy

not a good product, there are such better volumizing mascaras in the market! (cough cough Lamcome has some good ones). this one is heavy and it brings your lash curl down and it is super clumpy which makes it even harder to recurl your eyelash, it just doesnt do anything for me that is worth my hard earned money. im returning it!

It delivers and lasts long

I have been using this mascara for almost a year now. It’s a really good quality product, and I definitely recommend it. I am surprised at how long lasting this has been. Granted, I sometimes ran my brush under water to make it less dry. But that happened after months of usage and just to prolong the life of the product. I have naturally straight medium to short lashes, and I love the length and curl it gives especially. The only drawback that I had with this is that since it is 24 hour...

Volume fast

I have the sample bottle and put one coat on my lashes and that’s all I needed. I took my time and I’m actually not mad about it. I didn’t curl them before or separate them . I’m a mom and I need something that will make me look awake awake and this

Best mascara

I love this mascara! My lashes look longer and fuller. More importantly, it stays put! No more smudges and looking like a racoon. Just beautiful lashes.

Nope

I’m an absolute mascara enthusiast and nothing about this wowed me. I actually thought it was sub par for what I was expecting. Ladies save your money and go buy a different mascara.

Bottle nice, but doesn’t deliver results.

Dissapointed again: I expected this mascara to be awesome, given the cost, glass bottle, hype, and I am disappointed. It doesn’t build well, or curl, even with eyelash curler. It flakes like crazy, regardless of the 28 hours of wearing promised. The black is dull, and the quality of buildup is not great. I’ve been privileged to experience sampling many mascaras that were amazing, some even from the drug store, and over the years manufacturers have changed to these eco friendly formulas and...

Too heavy

I really wanted to like this. Unfortunately, it is very heavy on the lashes and weighs them down. Will not repurchase.

Really Like This

I keep waiting for this mascara to do what all the others do after a bit. Smudge, flake, lose it's curling power, get clumpy, but it won't. It's beautiful. I have really nice looking lashes when I use this. You definitely notice them even with eyeshadow on, which a lot of other mascaras weren't delivering on. This might be the mascara for me. I can build up volume, my curl lasts all day, it doesn't smudge unless I'm completely barefaced and don't apply setting powder … even then, it smudges...

I love this mascara would definitely buy again.

This mascara is amazing! It really makes your eyelashes look really big and pretty! Definitely recommend buying

Clumpy and thick

Extremely clumpy and thick, almost as if it were already expired (but it was a brand new tube).

Please make it transfer proof

For the price should be transfer proof. The rep at store recommended it but after using it, testing it out I can honestly say I don’t Love it. I tried not applying it to my bottom eyelashes but still see little grayish spots even from only apply ing to top eyelashes

WILL Smear Under Your Eyes

Girlies beware. I wore this in Chicago to the office on a humid day and oooooof. All of that dark looking shadow is mascara. It’s one of those mascaras that flake and smear and make you look exhausted. When I got home after work, where I sit sedentary for 8 hours in a cubicle, it looked like I had run a marathon. So I can’t imagine an actually physically demanding job.

Fan for Life

Easy to apply, easy to remove once I get some warm water on my eyes, comes off clean. Doesn't flake off ever during the day. I will be a fan for many years

I need another one!

It looked so good, my daughter wanted it, I think it looks good enough to buy the regular sized one. Its nice to be able to try it out before deciding if it works for you. I have bought mascara that irritated my eyes, maybe allergic to something. But not this one!

A must have !

[I received this product in exchange for my honest review] I'm seriously impressed with this mascara! The Exagger-eyes Volume Mascara delivers on its promise of big, bold lashes without clumping or flaking. The brush is perfectly shaped to grab every lash, adding both length and volume while keeping them separated. My lashes look fuller and more lifted with just one coat, but it layers beautifully if you want a more dramatic look. It also holds up all day without smudging—no raccoon eyes by...

A must have !

[I received this product in exchange for my honest review] I’m seriously impressed with this mascara! The Exagger-eyes Volume Mascara delivers on its promise of big, bold lashes without clumping or flaking. The brush is perfectly shaped to grab every lash, adding both length and volume while keeping them separated. My lashes look fuller and more lifted with just one coat, but it layers beautifully if you want a more dramatic look. It also holds up all day without smudging—no raccoon eyes by...

Love this product! Make lashes look full and long

Charlotte Tisburry mascara

Not crazy about it. Nothing great. I wouldn't pay full price for this product. Some of the L'Oréal mascara's are better

Everything you want in a mascara

This mascara delivers fullness, length and curl without clumping. It is water resistant, not waterproof, so it won't run if you get splashed or laugh a few tears. It removes easily with eye makeup remover.

Better than any other I've tried so far

Goes on so smoothly, no clumping. Love the brush, extends and separates the lashes, and looks great. Recommend trying to keep the bottle standing up.

Love this Mascara

I have the full size version of this mascara. I had the makeup artist for my daughter's wedding ask me which mascara I was using as she was impressed with how my eyes looked and the volume that I had. This mascara can take me from looking tired to looking like a star!!! Love it!! Please start carrying the full size in the store.

Love

[I received this product in exchange for my honest review] This mascara is amazing. It hold so well and definitely gives you volume. I use it on my top and bottom lashes. It’s adorable and has great ingredients.

Forever Love!

Hands down the best mascara I've ever tried and I've tried so many! Doesn't smudge (even when I'm sweating my butt of during a day of golfing) and doesn't flake. Gives amazing volume!

Great mascara

I have sparse and light eyelashes. I need a mascara that will really amp them up and this does it.

The best ever! 🤩

This is the best mascara ever! I wasn't blessed with natural long lashes and the results are amazing! It also comes off very easily without pulling your lashes off. It's worth the price and I will never use any other product ever again.

AMAZING

The best mascara I have ever used! It makes my eyelashes super long and the mascara holds up through the day. I have very watery eyes and I needed a mascara that will withstand that and this is THAT product. Highly recommend trying it out!

Great at first..

When I first tried the Charlotte Tilbury Exagger-Eyes Mascara, I loved the lift and definition it gave my lashes. Unfortunately, after several uses, the formula became too clumpy and hard to work with. It lost the smooth application I initially enjoyed, so I won’t be purchasing it again.

Amazing mascara, extra volumen my lashes look very very long

The mascara is pretty good and gives a nice look. It works well, but I feel there are other mascaras that offer similar results at a better price. Still, it’s a nice option if you want to try something new!

Must have mascara

This is the best mascara I have used. The wand helps with curling and creating volume. The mascara does not flake and is not clumpy. 10/10.

Mascara for length and volume

I really like this mascara. It really adds volume and length. But it can get clumpy. Overall 4/5!

# 1 ALL DAY EVERY DAY!

Best mascara EVER. Leaves lashes full and long! I used to use Lancôme Definicils but this took its place the moment I tried it. Washes off easily with remover and doesn’t flake. I love you for making this Charlotte!

The best!

Ive been trying several mascaras… and this is the best. One coat and my lashes are full and long. Not clumping. Does not give super racoon eyes when removing. Overall would recommend. 🧡

Not worth the money

I was looking for a mascara that would be better than Lancôme idole and was referred to this one. It's not even close.

Don't Waste Your Money

I had hopes this mascara would produce the results that I thought it would, however, the brush was very difficult to use to distribute the mascara without clumping. I will continue to stick with Hourglass mascara that always delivers a beautiful finish.

Not worth it

Very basic mascara, overrated as well. Won't buy again

Yet another disappointment from this line. My lashes don't stay curled and I end up with raccoon eyes by the end of the day. The mascara is very thickly coated on the brush. Another waste of $.

Product really did not provide a lot of volume and did not really stand out

Exceeded expectations

This mascara lives up to the hype. Worth the price. Makes my tiny lashes look long and thick.

It gave NOTHING

I thought with the curved brush it would really push up my lashes and give it lots of volume but it did NOTHING. I

The best mascara

Everytime I buy a mascara, I’m always left slightly disappointed — until I found this one. My lashes look amazing all day. They look extremely long, volumized and stay curled; which never happens for me. This is the best mascara I have ever used and 100% recommend it!

Lots of volume!

I got a sample of this mascara, and I am very impressed with the volume it gives my lashes!

A must-have for volumized lashes!

This mascara works wonders for short lashes! I will definitely purchase this again.

Nothing special.

It’s okay, kind of heavy on the lashes, volume is okay, length isn’t the best.

this is my new favorite mascara but it may not be for everyone it gives thick dramatic lashes that i personally do not find clumpy but some may. I absolutely love it and it lasts all way!

Not worth the money

Would like to give 5 stars but it comes off on your eyes in a few hours. Not worth the money

The Best!

I wasn't born with long lashes and this product gives me long lashes. I'm glad I purchased it.

Returned !!don't buy the hype!!

Does nothing that a good drugstore mascara doesn't. the big deal lash paradise is 10x better. I was so looking forward to trying charlotte tilbury but so far her products just aren't giving the price tag. I have tried every mascara out there. the only thing that makes this luxury is the glass bottle

Best mascara

This is the best mascara that I have ever used. Goes on easy and looks great all day. Makes my lashes look like I have extensions.

exagger-eyes

this mascara works so well for me! one of the best mascaras i have ever tried, and i've tried well over 40 mascaras. my thick, straight lashes refuse to stay curled for 5+ minutes with any other mascara. lash curlers do not work for me, either, but this mascara manages to curl my lashes and keep them curled all day! note: the brush picks up a lot of formula so just make sure you wipe off the excess to avoid clumping (common problem with any volumizing mascara out there). this is a wet...

It is such an amazing mascara ever which i used it curls and volums the lashes

Wouldn’t recommend

Do not recommend for eyelashes that are flat. Weighs heavy

Yes I would buy this product again.

I was very pleased at how well the mascara worked. It added a lot of length to my lashes

Nothing special

It’s good but nothing that a drugstore mascara didn’t already do. The essence lash princess performs same if not better than this one I was really hoping this mascara was as good as it claimed but sadly the before and after images are totally far fetched

very unhappy with this

With all the great reviews and Good Housekeeping saying it's a big fave for so many I was not impressed at all. It did not get the length of others I've tried (like the picture shows). And a rediculous amount of flaking. That is something I can not tolerate, especially from a "high end" mascara.

I would not buy this again.

I have very small lashes, the brush is thick and it doesn't really grab/separate my lashes. I've had better results with cheaper brands. Just jot for me.

No volume

It adds color by no volume

one of the best mascaras on the market!!!

words cannot describe how much I personally LOVE this mascara. One of the best mascaras I’ve ever tried. This mascara can last me a whole day without smudging. It holds my lashes up too. Love love love.

Returned

I was not impressed with this mascara. It just didnt work for me. Felt very wet and just looked bad. I returned it 😭 there are way better options for much cheaper.

Not worth the price

This is by far the worst mascara I have ever used. My lashes are already long and curly so i was looking for a mascara to thicken them up. Even after three coats, this does absolutely nothing. Do not waste your money.

I wouldn't buy this product again

I saw how popular this mascara was and decided to get it but it wasn't as expected. It came out of the tube too thick. It was too heavy and then it didn't last and I ended up with racoon eyes

It's okay

For the price, it isn't that great. Not buildable, doesn't seem to fill out or lengthen much.

Delivers on its promise!

I have been looking for the perfect mascara for a while and this really fit the bill. It looks great, lasts long, doesn't clump, smudge or run. I would definitely buy it again.

The holy grail of mascara

Charlotte really knew what she was doing when she came up with this mascara. I have no complaints other than its harder to wash off than my other mascaras I have used in the past, but thats not a deterrent for me in this case. The biggest plus is that I have not found it to smudge or leave black areas around my eyes and I LOVE that. For that reason I will always splurge on this mascara.

Great lengthening mascara. It does a great job at defining your lashes.

I use this over another CT mascara to add extra oomph! Great formula. I have no issues with flaking, smudging, or stiffness. Great rich color.

I am loving this product. The curl is unreal and it doesn't leave any gross residue after removing. It also doesn't make my eyelashes feel too heavy after applying.

Not a fan

I love the other Charlotte Tilbury pillow talk mascara, but this one is awful. Ive used about half this tube and kept hoping I'd grow to love it. Nope. Hate it even more now than I did at first.

Insane Volume That Lasts

This is one of my top 5 mascaras. It lasts all day with no clumping, smudging, or flaking. I love dramatic and voluminous lashes and this gives me exactly that. I can apply multiple coats and it won’t get clumpy.

Burn burn burn

This product doesn't provide thickening at all. The length was something I can get from a drugstore brand. My eyes started burning about an hour after applying. I will not definitely not buy again.

Solidly in my mascara rotation

I didn’t like this at first, but that was user error. Once I got used to the curved brush and intense formula, I fell in love. It reminds me of my favorite Bite mascara that is now extinct. It’s a wetter formula, but it works.

perfect mascara

an ulta associate recommended this for me because i was struggling with my mascara lasting all day and smearing under my eyes. this solved both of those problems and gives a very natural but enhanced look. i love how voluminous it makes my lashes look! the shape is perfect for getting the inner corners too

Love

Love this product it feels light on my lashes. So far it’s my go to mascara. It’s easy to brush through to not clump

I normally don’t do reviews, but this mascara really thick and legs in curls. I’ve had it for over 12 hours no flaking nothing. I love it

Worth it

Didn't believe this mascara could make my lashes look longer but it worked; no more wasteful, unnecessary spending. Very satisfied with this product.

Would buy again

Love it

My favourite mascara.

I have tried several Lancome mascaras and YSL Lash Clash mascara. CT Exagger-eyes mascara beats them all. No clumping, no smudging, no flaking. Formula is just right, not dry or too wet. Love the curved brush. I recommended this mascara twice while shopping at Sephora. It's the mascara of my dreams.

Loooong dry time!

Way too wet . Thought it would be great but was difficult to apply. Ended up with more on my lids. I returned it.

Best Mascara, EVER!

If you're looking for a new masacara, this is it! It applies very smoothly, no clumpiness, non-dry/heavy feeling. My new favorite. I went from Too Faced's, Better Than Sex, to every bottle of Mascara frim Benefit. And although I do like Fanfest from Benefit, the formula dries out rather quickly… so, Tilbury's Exxager-Eyes is here to stay!

A must have mascara!

Amazing mascara! I repurchased it twice and will do it again. It makes my lashes long and full.

Not Impressed

Very goopy, very clumpy.

Must Have!

I get so many compliments when I wear this. I love that it has a curved wand. It really helps to curl the lashes. It also gives the lashes more volume without being clumpy. It is definitely something I will keep purchasing.

Faux Lash Look

It’s excellent. This coats your lashes without being clumpy which is my main issue with mascaras. This however seems to check every box. Non clumpy, even coverage through with just 1 layer, THICKENS and lengthens. What more should you want? If you’re looking for a bit of a faux lash look or exaggerated eyes this is perfect. Great product.

No clumping, easy to put on, volume and length!

I bought the mini size of this and have had it a few months. It has been one of my go to mascaras and I am picky! It doesn't irritate my eyes like some of the viral mascaras. I plan to purchase the full size next

Not worth the money

I’ve been using this product for about a month now, and while it’s not the worst one I’ve tried, there are far better ones available at the drugstore. This one flakes throughout the day and doesn’t hold.

Save your money

Total disappointment! Only thing exaggerated was the picture on the box.. this did absolutely nothing for my lashes . I have drugstore mascara 100 times better .. honestly I haven't been wowed by any of the CT products so far esp for the price

It’s good but…

Great mascara but hard on the lashes. First impression was a clumpy mess. Removal isn’t very smooth. They do look though with just combing them out after. I would probably buy it again.

Stunning Eye lashes!!!

OMG perfect!!! Dramma Eyes!!! The best one!!! Volume and curve! My lashes are short and straight and with this mask they look fabulous!!!

Great but fragile tube!

While this wasn’t absolutely perfect, it is still the best mascara I have found so that’s why I’m giving it 5 stars. It washed off easily, didn’t give me raccoon eyes, and did a good job at providing both length and volume without getting clumpy or flaking throughout the day. However, I am going to try other mascaras this sale because when I was only maybe halfway through the tube I accidentally dropped it while getting ready one morning and the glass tube broke. I can be a little clumsy and...

Great

[I received this product in exchange for my honest review] Great product. It flakes but all do for me. It lasts all day. Doesn't clump. Goes on smoothly. Slightly pricey. Other than that, it's a great product.

Great

[I received this product in exchange for my honest review] Great product, it flakes a bit but all of them do for me.

Not worth the money

Lumpy finish. Worst mascara I’ve ever used. Used it two times and threw it away.

Best Mascara ever

This is the best mascara I have ever used and I am so picky. I usually have to use waterproof mascara however this one isnt waterproof and it last all day. It doesn't come off or smudge. It doesn't run done my wues making me look like a raccoon. I can cry, work out and sweat, it doesn't not budge. I love the way it make my eyelashes look. I loke voulme something thay thickens my lashes. I am lucky to have already long lashes. This does help with leanth. It has longevity. It has a thicker...

Results not as advertised

I had high hopes for this because of the results on the advertising and packaging. It's true, this product won't budge or smudge all day/night long. However, it is very difficult to remove with my dual phase eye makeup remover. Tugging on my delicate eye area to get mascara off is not my idea of a good time. As a 50-something, I'm dealing with the lines and thin skin in that area already, and sleeping with raccoon eyes is not my preference.

Excellence in a bottle

Excellence in a bottle. EXCELLENCE. I have thick lashes but this uplifts them and makes them just POP. THANK YOU MISS TILBURY I LOVE YOU

Perfection

I have long straight lashes. This mascara actually holds the curl from my eye lash curler! It’s fantastic! I love everything about it!

Love it!

Great mascara! Gave me lots of volume after my lash extensions were removed and I needed some volume and curl! Love it and worth the money for this brand!

Clumpy and flaky

The glass packaging is gorgeous and feels very luxe! The wand bristles are thick and the curve makes it really easy to apply on top and bottom lashes. The color is a deep black for bold lashes. I gave 3 stars because the formula is clumpy and flaky. It’s also really difficult to remove. One of my least favorite lash formulas.

Great results

Love the results, great for a very dramatic look, lasts a long time, waterproof and tears approved! Easy to apply but you have to be careful the first time

Not a fan

I was very disappointed in this mascara. It made my lashes clump together. The product also seemed to get dry in the tube very quickly.

BEST MASCARA I HAVE EVER USED!!!

If you’re like me & you like your lashes to look super long, but also have that nice volume without mascara clumping them together, then this is definitely the best mascara for you! I have tried SO many mascaras and stumbled upon this one in Sephora’s store, so I tried the sample & was literally mind blown! It gives you that nice, long length, but the bristles separate your lashes so well to give you that volume as well. I used to wear false lashes all the time, but I literally stopped...

Will not buy again

I am disappointed in this mascara. I don't know if it's because I didn't understand the description when purchasing online or not. This mascara, when applied, only makes my lash look clumpy. I don't like it and would not recommend to my friends.

Best mascara ever!

Its the best mascara ive ever used!

New Fav

PMG dark star mascara has been my holy grail for years and decided to give this mascara a try. This mascara wasn’t my favourite when it was brand new but as I’ve used it more it is amazing, it gives me the look of wearing falsies without the hassle.

Wet + stays wet for a while. Clumping.

I am a Mascara Freak. And have a whole bunch of them. I was kind of excited to try and after I purchased one and went home I removed my make up and dried my face. And finally got to try this. It was a little hard to build. Started clumping when tried to layer and it is wet. Plus took forever to get it dried. It stays wet for a while. Maybe that’s why it was kind of hard to layer…?? I already have long lashes so I wasn’t too sure about it’s lengthening part and about the volume since it was...

The GOAT

FINALLY I have found my mascara. After purchasing a mini, I fell in love with this mascara. Im trying to get my lashes back to a healthier state after years of strip lashes. My are short and sparse. With the help of this mascara I can see the growth progressing. I have zero flaking or smudging. It lasts all day, even through workouts and tanning. The packaging in the full size is gorgeous. Its so worth the $

A little disappointed

Overall it's a decent mascara, but not what I was hoping for. The formula is a little clumpy and does add volume, but not the length I've seen advertised in pictures. I'm just glad I tried the travel size first before buying the full size. Probably won't purchase again.

Love

It was so hard for me to throw away this mascara after using it for six months usually, I rotate them every three months, but I just really didn't want to get rid of this one because it was my new favorite since I started using it! I got several compliments on my lashes and I trust that this one will wear nicely all day long and not transfer to my under eyes.

I wanted to try out a new mascara and this one exceeded my expectations! I love how my lashes look and it doesn’t flake.

Works wonders

I have terrible, thin, straight, sparse, light-colored lashes. This gives the best results of any mascara I've tried. It lifts, lengthens and curls. It's pricey but it works! And it works within the first coat or two.

So Much Potential, but the Flaking Ruined It

Charlotte Tilbury can do no wrong in my eyes—except when it comes to this mascara. I was counting down the days until its release, and at first, I was convinced it would be my new favorite. The packaging is gorgeous, housed in what feels like a luxe, heavy glass tube. The formula is intensely black, making my lashes look bold and dramatic. Then came the flaking. And wow, does it flake. Within hours, I had little black specks all over my face. No matter how stunning it looked initially, I...

Absolutely Perfect

First time application. This mascara takes my thin and blond lashes to the next level. I will report later if it flakes or doesn’t last - or doesn’t wash off. But right now all 5 different brands I have bought in the past are in the garbage! Thank you CT - now don’t change it or stop making it please.

Wouldn’t buy again

Using this product after a few hours my eyes begin to itch. It also flaked off.

A must have

Love so far iv only used it a couple of times but definitely will buy again

Worth the money!

This stuff is amazing. I typically don't go for expensive mascaras but the reviews were so good I bought the travel size to try. Holy crap! The length with this mascara is SO good. I curled my lashes and used primer beforehand, applied 2 coats and I'm really pleased with the results. Before and after pic posted. I'll definitely have to buy the full size tube when the travel size is empty!

Seemed dried out or not enough product

I bought the sample size to try the product and i double coated my lashes and didnt see any difference in my lashes with this product that i wouldn't get with other mascaras. I feel people with longer lashes will get a better results then those with shorter ones. I'm i only bought the sample size and not the full size and i'm glad i didnt spend the money on the full size one as this product seemed like it was drying out or didn't have enough product on it.

Literally can’t live without

I literally get asked what mascara I’m using all the time lol

LOVE ITTTTT

this is one of the best mascara I ever tried. stays all day and doesn't ruin the makeup, I love this product, for me one of the best!!

Lengthens and Thickens

Lengthens and thickens beautifully. Better than any other product I’ve used

Wow lashes!

No clumping or smudging. Gives great big , beautifully separated long lashes.

Charlotte Tilbury exagger-eyes mascara

I've been a mascara junky all my adult years. This is without a doubt the best mascara I've ever used. It gives incredible length and thickens lashes and is never clumpy.

Best mascara I've used

It holds my lashes perfectly. doesn't smudge and doesn't drop my eyelashes.

I like it!

I can usually tell if I'll like a mascara from the wand. This is a nice mascara, gives you some length and volume, doesn't smudge or flake. It doesnt smudge or stick to the skin when youre washing your makeup off which is something I really hate when mascaras do. It washes off similarly to another tubing mascara I own. Im not sure if this one is a tubing mascara? I got a sample for points at the other store LOL but Im buying a full size from Ulta.

Raccoon eyes

Beware of raccoon eyes! This product is not for sensitive eyes! It looks nice upon application, and that's it.

This mascara was so good I bought it for the second time.

Wow!

I love this mascara! I was able to get volume and length out of it. It looks great!

gorgeous lashes

the formula is a bit dry, but once u build it up two layers it is very black and makes the lashes look very thick

So so

Applicator is nice but flakes so bad and makes me look like I have black circles under my eyes.

All Time Favorite Mascara!

I have been using the same mascara for the past 2 years, i finally decided i wanted to try something else. I stumbled upon this as a sample. Let’s just say i will never be going back. This mascara doesn’t flake, is sweat resistant, and VERY lightweight. definitely one of my favoritites!

I love this mascara! It makes my eyelashes look so thick and full.

I would not buy this product again

I came in asking for the Lancôme Idol mascara unfortunately they were out of. I have a couple other go to's. I was approached by an assisted saying this mascara doesn't clump & that package is glass. It does clump & not separate hate the brush.

This is the worst mascara I have used in a very long time. It’s clumpy and makes my lashes look horrible. I have barely used it and it looks like it’s already dry and old.

Love this mascara

This is my all time fav it last all day and still holds up with out flakes or running

meh

Gor a tube with my 100 points, let me first say the tube is the size of my pinky finger. Smallest 100 point mascara I have ever received. Nothing to write home about, an average mascara for a high price. I will stick to my others-Haus labs, Pat mcgrath and hourglass. Also flaked under my eyes.

Nice mascara but a bit pricey

I got this product for free from influenster and charlottetilbury in exchange for my honest review. I have heard such good things from this brand but they are a little pricey so I was excited to get this. The bottle is glass so a little heavy to hold on to but it makes it look pretty. The mascara goes on ok but it clumps up a little on the lashes. I didn't get a big effect from it but it did make my lashes look bigger. I don't think I would repurchase.@influenster #complimentary...

Nice mascara but a little pricey

I got this product for free from @influenster and charlottetilbury in exchange for my honest review. I have heard such good things from this brand but they are a little pricey so I was excited to get this. The bottle is glass so a little heavy to hold on to but it makes it look pretty. The mascara goes on ok but it clumps up a little on the lashes. I didn't get a big effect from it but it did make my lashes look bigger. I don't think I would repurchase.@influenster #complimentary...

Love it

Must try!! Makes my lashes look SOOOOO GORGEOUS and adds so much length!!

Not a fan

Dried out very quickly and flaked

My new go to!

I love it!! It makes my lashes so long and doesn’t clump of cake! Easy to take off as well.

Disappointed… Lancôme is way better

I have been using it for about a month now. From the description and picture I was expecting a result similar than what you would get from Lancôme Hypnose Drama of Mr Big. But nope. It does not lengthen the lashes and cannot compare to Lancôme in my opinion. Waste of money.

Perfect consistency, long-lasting

I got a sample with my last purchase, and I’m so glad I did! This mascara has a perfect consistency that applies smoothly and evenly. It stays on my lashes all day without smudging or flaking, and I never have to worry about it leaving marks around my eyes. Truly long-lasting and reliable—definitely a must-have in my makeup routine!

Doesn’t make the eyelashes longer. I also don’t like the brush.

The only mascara you need

I can’t live without this mascara! I love that it curls, lengthens and makes my lashes look so voluminous! You will love it! ❤️

Beautiful!

I'm kind of amazed by this mascara! I wear makeup everyday and have used lots of mascaras and this one is really special! Gives you the most beautiful jet black, long, thickened, curled lashes that don't flake or smudge! Really recommend!

Not for me, but not bad

As a former professional makeup artist, I wanted to love this. I love the other results I see online with the posted reviews. I was disappointed with how many applications to build a lash look I prefer. I don’t dislike it, it’s just not for my thin eyelashes.

Very good

Almost perfect. It looks great and removes easily. It flakes off though after 9 hours. Even with that, I’ll repurchase.

Absolutely AMAZING!!!

This mascara is by far one of my favorites. I never had any issues with clumping like I have had with other brands. It made my lashes so much longer looking plus they seemed like they had a little curl to them! Not to mention this is smudge proof!!

It’s completely overrated and nothing special. I purchased it based on its recommendation as a best-seller, but it fell far short of expectations. The was disappointing and and defiantly was not worth the hype and tbe price performance performance The performance was disappointing, and it definitely wasn’t worth the hype or the price. This version maintains your tone of disappointment while being concise and

New favourite mascara

Absolutely love this stuff it doesn’t transfer and it volumizes and lengthens your lashes a lot! this is definitely my new fav mascara :)

A MUST HAVE mascara

I was in desperate need of a good mascara as my eyelashes are long but super thin. This was the PERFECT one. I knew by looking at the brush this was gonna be perfect and it did not disappoint! I love the way my lashes look with this product and it compares to no other

Amazing but clumpy!

I love this mascara. It my lashes very long. I have two complaints though. First, it falls very quickly. This isn’t much of a problem for me since I’m constantly re curling my lashes, but it is something to note. Second, it is quite clumpy. I love the look though! something to notes

I like it, didn’t need it

Super pretty gives me a great fanned out look without flaking ! Holds a curl okay, makes my lashes super dark. Not a need to have, drug store works just as good for less, but not mad about it !

tbh let down

i liked it and it immediately lengthened my lashes as soon as i applied after curling but they fell and it was disappointing. lowk dont buy it if u wanna save ur money but wtv

Great mascara

I received a sample of this mascara and I fell in love with it. This doesn't flake off or smear, giving raccoon eyes. Before this mascara, I always had to check under my eyes wipe off the excess that would fall. Finally I came across a mascara where I don't have to do that. I am hoping they'll come out with a brown color

Get it!

Best mascara on the market. Holds a curl and lifts lashes without any flaking throughout the day and no transfer!

CT mascara

It was really good

Ditched everything for this mascara

This mascara is the absolute best i've ever tried!! No smudge, no flakes, stays on throughout the day, and does an amazing job of holding my curl!!

Caused eyelash loss

I bought this mascara because of the reviews and hype it received online. At first I really liked it! It added the length and volume I was looking for. After a few uses, I noticed eyelash loss. Now I have a patch of eyelashes missing. Will not buy again.

Hope Exagger-eyes by CT is here to stay

I started using Exagger-eyes mascara 3 months ago when I purchased it rather than getting my usual product. I am so Happy and Pleased that I did. Beginning with the first application I have been thrilled with the ease this stuff adheres to my lashes , and Ev even if I don’t curl my lashes the wand does a decent job of lifting them. However, when I use my eyelash curler first, watch out, placing mascara onto WOW, it makes my eye lashes look like they’re false. I haven’t received so many...

THE BEST!

Trust me - I have tried them all.

It’s Okay

This is a good mascara but it wasn’t anything life changing for me. I have fine lashes and it seemed to weigh them down, but it did give me good volume.

luv

Does not run at all super volumizing. highly recommend

My new mascara

It lasts while you’re wearing it but also comes off easy at the end of the night! I love it

Fabulous Dahling

This is my fav CT mascara - it gives me va-va voom and best of all no raccoon eyes!

Great!

This mascara does extremely well in longevity, isn't flaky, is volumizing, and the formula remains consistent. Some mascaras are only good for a small period of time, but this one applies consistently throughout the time I've had it. It stays on all day, looking fresh through the whole day. There's no smudging throughout the day and no flaking. It doesn't give the spider leg look either. It is a solid black color. I have sensitive eyes and skin, but this doesn't bother me. The only...

Loveeeeee!

I love this mascara I think this is comparable to the MAC Stack mascara that was released not that long ago. It definitely makes my eyelashes look fake. Will be repurchasing this. The packaging is also very luxurious.

Honest

I got a sample size for free when I bought something, tried it and fell in love!! It is long lasting. I cannot stress that enough.!! it does not flake. It does not smear. Its light weight it's honestly everything it says.. and that is very surprising to me lol!

Love this mascara!

This is an amazing product with an awesome volume effect and the ingredient analysis makes it have a great application technique and sustainable impact. The packaging design is gorgeous!

Love this mascara !

This is an amazing product with an awesome volume effect and the ingredient analysis makes it have a great application technique and sustainable impact. The packaging design is gorgeous!

Ended up returning

The mascara packaging is very nice and I initially bought it for the packaging and because I like charlotte tilbury. However the mascara is to heavy and doesn’t really add volume.

Made Eyelashes Look Weighted Down

Loved this mascara initially but over a short time sadly realized it’s not a fit for me because it’s too wet ( gets all over eye lids) before drying and once it dries it makes my lashes look heavy and dry.

Never again.

It's the worst mascara ever. Eyelashes become heavy and do not keep shape. The mascara is falling off and it's very hard to wash it off.

I will buy again

Without a doubt this mascara is the best out there along with all of Charlotte Tilburys line!! The Best definitely.

No flaking or smudging

After trying sample of mascaras & buying a bunch of brands this mascara is the only one that does smudge to my eyelids throughout the day! Which has been a huge struggle finding the right one. It is thicker so I apply slowly to avoid clumping.

Def buying again

No questions asked, this easily replaced my favorite tubing mascara!!! I have reallllly sensitive eyes and I need a mascara that doesn't flake! This one grips on so lightly that it lifts my lashes and feels like it nourishes! Def worth the money!

Def buying again

Def replaces my favorite tubing mascara, this one feels like my lashes are getting some kind of nourishment, and doesn’t bother my sensitive eyes throughout the day or when washing it off

It’s a meh

It’s meh. I really had higher hopes for charlotte tilbury products but so far they’ve all let me down.

great mascara , adds thickness, love and recommend

Not impressed

Was very clumpy and did not define my lashes at all. There are so many other brands that are so much better than this one, like fenty, Dior, etc. I am immediately returning it.

I feel as if this product weighed down my lashes a lot. It did separate and give a lot of volume, but I was not impressed. My lashes felt heavy. And the bottle is really heavy and make sure to close it properly!

My new holy grail!

This mascara has become a holy grail for me. It lengthens and makes my lashes look full with no clumping. I don't put powder over my concealer, and this mascara does NOT leave me raccoon eyes which is amazing. It looks just as good in the morning as it does when I come home from work. I adore this mascara!

Bomb Mascara!

Love the glass bottle! Packaging is amazing. A lot of product from what I can see. Super easy to apply and is very buildable for volume. Formula is great and it did not affect my eyes. Very very easy to remove. I love it.

Bomb Mascara!

Love the glass bottle! Packaging is amazing. A lot of product from what I can see. Super easy to apply and is very buildable for volume. Formula is great and it did not affect my eyes. Very very easy to remove. I love it.

Great product!

Really love this product and it truly thickens my lashes!

A love affair

I’ve been on the hunt for a good mascara, previously using the beauty lash clash and Illia. This formula takes the cake - I have short thin lashes but this makes them into a whole other level. It lasts without fall out or shrinkage. I never used to use mascara on the bottom lashes because other formulas would end up leaving me with raccoon/ dark eyes by mid day. But that’s over now. My lashes are long and defined. I’ve always liked mascara before but now I feel naked if I don’t use it. ...

Bad allergic reaction to my eyes I can’t stop itching

awesome!!!!!

now my lashes are long but have been short recently and i decided instead of a cheap mascara i wohdl get a more expensive mascara so i got the tester of the CT mascara. my first thought of fhis mascara was yea its good its kinda like every other mascara, it made my lashes look long and they stayed curled , so i added a second coat, it wasnt too thick nor clumpy but not natural either. it kinda gives you the thicker, fuller lashes.

awesome!!!!!

now my lashes are long but have been short recently and i decided instead of a cheap mascara i wohdl get a more expensive mascara so i got the tester of the CT mascara. my first thought of fhis mascara was yea its good its kinda like every other mascara, it made my lashes look long and they stayed curled , so i added a second coat, it wasnt too thick nor clumpy but not natural either. it kinda gives you the thicker, fuller lashes.

Great mascara

Charlotte Tilbury's Exagger-Eyes Volume Mascara is a game-changer for anyone seeking to elevate their lash game. The sleek, elegant packaging immediately catches the eye, embodying the brand's luxe aesthetic. Upon application, the mascara delivers impressive volume and length, creating a dramatic effect that enhances the eyes beautifully. Overall, Charlotte Tilbury's Exagger-Eyes Volume Mascara is a must-try for anyone looking to achieve voluminous, striking lashes. It combines quality with...

Great mascara

Charlotte Tilbury's Exagger-Eyes Volume Mascara is a game-changer for anyone seeking to elevate their lash game. The sleek, elegant packaging immediately catches the eye, embodying the brand's luxe aesthetic. Upon application, the mascara delivers impressive volume and length, creating a dramatic effect that enhances the eyes beautifully. The formula is rich and creamy, gliding on effortlessly without clumping or flaking throughout the day. It features a unique brush design that separates...

Doesn't hold curls

I love the glass bottle, and how beautiful it looks. Very regal. Unfortunately it stopped there for me. The formula is very thick and clumpy almost. I didnt see any real drama with this. Didnt keep my curl, and didnt lengthen. If thickening is what u are after this is for you. I think it would have been much better if the wand wasnt so short. A long teddy bear wand with little grabbing bristles to pull shorter lashes would be great for this. Just didnt love this.

Where is the volume or length?

After I purchased the lipliner and gloss, also the face cream, which I absolutely love! This being said, the mascara was a disappointment. I have fine eyelashes and I really tried everything to get any length or volume. It was thick and gave me clumpy eyelashes. I am 60+ young and tried many different brands. I will go back to my proofready mascara, which can be found at ulta too. Very sad that this brand is not great with all their products!

Less than desirable

Highly overrated. Sticking with Benefit Mascaras. I am South Korean so I have mono lids with the straightest lashes ever that don’t hold a curl to save my life! This just made my eyes a mess, no length at all, and no volume. Not a fan at all.

My favorite mascara

I have tried so many drugstore mascaras and high end mascaras and this is the BEST mascara I have used. I'm still searching for one that isn't waterproof and doesn't bring down my curl (I have straight lashes and have to curl them), but this one brings it down the least. Just one light swipe gives me significant volume and length. Its very buildable and easy to remove. I am in love with this formula and I highly recommend it.

Crummy mascara

This looks nice for a very short time. It flakes off and makes my eyes burn and tear every time I wear it. It’s also hard to remove, which is weird, you’d think with as much flaking it would come off easily.

As Advertised

The model pictures tell no lies. Very exaggerated but very natural and last my whole 8 hour shift. I will be getting the full size now b/c i think the longer wand will make it easier to hit angles.

Disappointed

I’ve been looking for a YSL Lash Clash cruelty free dupe, so I had high hopes for this new CT mascara. First impression was that it’s very wet. I thought giving it a week or so would help it dry down, but it still stays wet long after applying. It’s also clumpy with 2-3 coats, and I have a hard time keeping it off my lids. It does give good length and volume, and it lasts all day. It’s hard to remove - almost impossible. I use a cleansing oil first, then a makeup removing cleanser, then an...

I already have long, thick eyelashes, but this mascara did not hold up. It flakes off after a couple of hours and is very drying. Save your money.

I bought the mini size to try and loved it. It keeps my lashes looking full and curled and they stay that way until I remove my make up. I bought the full size as it’s my current favourite mascara.

I love it

amazing it works like magic, just as descried and it lasted all night.

Not for me

At first when I put it on it did gave me thick lashes with lots of volume with length , but than 4 hours later I look like a raccoon mascara was smeared off like if I was crying I really wanted to love it , hopefully they make a waterproof version maybe I will give it another try if they do

What a mess. It literally did everything they said it wouldn’t. Smudge, flake, etc. Disappointed.

Love it!

It definitely adds volume & doesn't flake off into my eyes.

SKIP!!

made my lashes clump & fall. wayyyy to heavy of a formula, not great for straight lashes.

Great mascara!

I absolutely love this mascara! It makes my eyes look super full without any clumpiness. While I have to apply a few coats to achieve the desired look, the end result is definitely worth it. Plus, it doesn't flake throughout the day, which is a huge plus for me!

One of my favorite mascaras. It definitely gives volume.

Nice product

I received this product for free in exchange for a review. The mascara is somewhat easy, but easy to remove with an oil cleanser. The mascara is a bit thick so you have to be careful there. It doesn't quite keep my short straight lashes curled, but otherwise does the job.

The mascara is somewhat easy, but easy to remove with an oil cleanser. The mascara is a bit thick so you have to be careful there. It doesn’t quite keep my short straight lashes curled, but otherwise does the job.

Not bad

The mascara is somewhat easy, but easy to remove with an oil cleanser. The mascara is a bit thick so you have to be careful there. It doesn't quite keep my short straight lashes curled, but otherwise does the job.

New favorite mascara

I usually stick to drugstore mascaras because I’ve never been able to find anything worth the splurge at Sephora. This is completely so worth it. My eyelashes or short and nonexistent. This mascara makes a huger difference in my look. Already bought a backup

WEAK Mascara

This was a very mediocre mascara. This offered very little volume. There are better mascaras at the drugstore. Not worth the money at all.

It’s a no for me, darling

Not a fan. The mascara goes on nicely however the product requires multiple layers and can get clunky quickly. The mascara has ZERO staying power. It flakes and gets into my eyes and by mid day there is noticeable coverage loss. Don’t waste your money. difference

Volumizing and long lasting. Would give 5 stars but can be clumpy but a great mascara overall

I wanted to check out this new mascara, but unfortunately it was rather disappointing: clumpy formula that is weighing-down your lashes, heavy bottle that is awkward to hold. Returned after 3 uses and back to using my all time favourite MERIT mascara

You need it!

You need this mascara, it does not bleed at all! Definitely worth the hype! This

The best mascara out there

I have tried at least a dozen different mascaras over the past few months trying to find the perfect one for me, amd the search stopped here. This mascara gave me everything i was looking for jn a mascara, and then some! Length, non-clumping, volume, and overall beautiful lashes. Its also cheaper than half of the other mascaras I tried.

Love it

I love this mascara I don’t run into clumping and it layers nicely. I also love that I have oily lids and this doesn’t transfer or flake at all and I have worn it for 16+ hours. I’m also really into packaging and the glass container is luxurious.

A no for me.

I won’t lie, I was not a fan of this mascara. The bottle firstly is too big & bulky. Secondly the formula is messy & clumpy. I love Charlotte Tilbury products but mascara is not their strong suit.

Skip This One

This mascara gave my lashes a nice curl, which I really appreciated. I loved the rich, dark color, as it added a bold, dramatic look. However, I found that it fell short in a few key areas. The formula tended to be clumpy and flaked throughout the day, which was disappointing. It also proved to be quite messy to remove, taking more effort than I'd like for a product I use daily. Normally, I love products from Charlotte Tilbury, but this one was a miss for me.

Just Ok…I’d skip this one.

This mascara gave my lashes a nice curl, which I really appreciated. I loved the rich, dark color, as it added a bold, dramatic look. However, I found that it fell short in a few key areas. The formula tended to be clumpy and flaked throughout the day, which was disappointing. It also proved to be quite messy to remove, taking more effort than I’d like for a product I use daily. Normally, I love products from Charlotte Tilbury, but this one was a miss for me.

Doesn’t curl your eyelashes

Returning - does not curl your eyelashes, it straightens them

I would not buy this product

This mascara tends to clump easily, resulting in a cakey finish that detracts from its overall appearance. While it does provide noticeable lash lengthening, the clumpy texture gives the impression of an old, dried-out formula. Not ideal for a polished, defined look.

The QUINTESSENTIAL Mascara

I can actually go without false lashes! This mascara is easy to remove, and goes on easily with fabulous results.

Love this!

Best mascara I have ever tried and it's waterproof, worked through tears and sweat after long day on the road

Great

I love this mascara! It literally does what i needed two mascaras and at least four coats to do, but in two coats instead. i have naturally long lashes and I curl them. I don't get as much mascara on my lid with this one as I have always with others. I love the glass bottle, and the design of this product. I used They're Real by Benefit Cosmetics for the past ten years, and was so upset when they changed the formula after a while to make it easier to get off. I like that this mascara is long...

Disappointed

Takes forever to dry so it ends up all over your eyelids. Also it either flakes or collects lint as I had a lot of trouble with my contacts when using it.

Difficult to remove.

Very difficult to remove. I lost 6 lashes the first (and last) time I removed it. I have a few types of oil-based eye makeup removers and this mascara didn't budge. I tossed it in the garbage. Who wants to lose eyelashes.

In the description they fail to mention that this only works on curly lashes or bottom lashes! I have very straight lashes so I curled mine and put it on and then not even thirty seconds later I looked in the mirror and my lashes had already went back to normal (flat and invisible). I don’t know what to do because I’ve tried other mascaras and they do the same thing for me! Someone please help! looked in the m

Not worth it

Didn’t love it. Very messy, ended up returning it.

Wouldn’t buy again

Nothing special. The loreal voluminous does a better chop and is half the cost. Returning it

Not worth the hype

I bought this item as per rave reviews & it is a nice mascara but it was thick & wasn’t as expected, I think the formula could be thinner & less goopy & my lashes look the same? One brand on each eye - can you tell which side is CT?

Love

Easy application with excellent results! Was asked if my lashes were false! Exceeded expectations.

Legitimately best I have tried in a while!

I have tried countless mascaras within different price ranges. Telescopic is a favorite. However, when I tried this, I was blown away. I will say my goal is to volumize, not lengthen. Your lashes will look fantastic. It also doesn't irritate my eyes, and I wear contacts daily. Packaging is top-tier but should be expected at this price point. I am in grad school and will continue breaking my student budget with this mascara. I will say if your goal is to lengthen, this is more of a volumizing product.

Not worth trying

I've purchased several different mascaras (expensive & drugstore) and couldn't wait to try this one from CT. Unfortunately, it turned out to be one of the worst I've ever tried. The brush is to large which caused a smudging mess all over my eye lids. The formula just made my lashes fall flat, no volume or curl. It will separate your lashes but in a clumpy "spider lash" way. I quickly returned it to the store. It was to expensive to lack all of results it promised.

Incredible

The firsy CT product that I LOVE! Lengthens and in the Florida heat stays up all say!!

Mediocre at best.

I love CT but just can’t seem to like any of her mascaras. This one, when you first use is pretty decent, dark, covers well. But after a full days use, it gets crumbly IMO. I’ll usually find I feel something irritating my eye, so I go check and it just crumbles apart. After a few weeks it seems to just dry up so fast in the glass bottle. I’ve tried better. to

ADD TO CART!

This is hands down the best mascara I have ever used. It is a must-have and will be a frequent purchase after I run out.

Best Mascara

I've tried dozens and dozens of mascaras and Charlotte Tilbury Exsgger-eyes Volume Mascara is the absolute best. No smudging and no flaking after wearing a full day. I blink a lot because of dry eyes so no smudging and no flaking are very important to me. Removing the mascara is very easy too.

Mascara

I've never used this brand before, but I've seen it on commercials and I had to try it. I totally love it, love the volume that it gives me and the way it makes my lashes looks.

Great mascara but irritated my eye ?

I’ve been using this for weeks I love the look of it, I love how easily it comes off, but I noticed ever since I tried it my right eye has been twitching when I wear it, and I wear it everyday

Like it

I actually like this mascara, it goes on very nicely doesn’t clump up and look a mess. It definitely gives length and volume, and I like how the tube has some weight to it, it’s very different but oddly satisfying.

Like it

I actually like this mascara, it goes on very nicely doesn't clump up and look a mess. It definitely gives length and volume, and I like how the tube has some weight to it, it's very different but oddly satisfying.

Best mascara ever

OMG! Best mascara ever! I have tried them all....So glad Amber at the store recommended it! Doesn't smudge or clump and my lashes look incredible!

Love it

The glass packaging makes it look luxurious, I loved it. As for the product, I really liked it, it gave me volume, I really liked it. And it’s waterproof

Very good

The glass packaging makes it look luxurious, I loved it. As for the product, I really liked it, it gave me volume, I really liked it, and it is waterproof.

Over-priced mascara

There is nothing special about this mascara! Very disappointed. I was hoping for exceptional results but my $8 L’Oréal mascara is just as good!

Beautiful

This is my first Tilbery product and I have to say l'm not disappointed. I've wanted to try her products for a long time. This mascara is beautiful. I would really recommend trying it! This was given to me as a free sample.

Beautiful

This is my first Tilbery product and I have to say l'm not disappointed. I've wanted to try her products for a long time. This mascara is beautiful. I would really recommend trying it! This was given to me as a free sample.

Don't buy this

This is the wrost mascara ive ever gotten, i came it so many chances. Every time i took off my makeup it pulled so many lashed & i dont wipe off my mascara harsh. I take it off line i take off any other mascara i loose about 5-10 lashes everytime.

A must have mascara!

The best volumizing mascara! People have asked if I am wearing fake lashes. Love how conditioning it is and the ingredients are great. And of course, love the packaging - chic as usual!

Love this mascara!

The best volumizing mascara! People have asked if I am wearing fake lashes. Love how conditioning it is and the ingredients are great. And of course, love the packaging - chic as usual!

Love it!

I really like this mascara. It does not give me raccoon eyes. It does not clump. One coat gives me nice volume. And I love the packaging!

Do not purchase

This product is extremely thick. It goes on clumpy and way too thick and wet. Does not give what it says it gives. I have naturally long lashes and this just made them clump together and look awful.

great mascara

This picture is one layer after 5 hours, one of the best mascaras I have had so far. it gets better and better after a few times using it.

Exaggerated expectations...

Disappointed, I love Charlotte Tilbury products, but this mascara is first of all, over priced, secondly is thick and clumpy on the lashes and difficult to remove. I returned it for full refund.

I love! It shows my lashes 🥰

The mascara is very black! It is easy to use and it is very buildable. If you have short lashes, you are able to separate them easily as well as boost how long they are!

I love! It shows my lashes!

The mascara is very black! It is easy to use and it is very buildable. If you have short lashes, you are able to separate them easily as well as boost how long they are!