Eye Want You Lengthening + Volumizing Clean Mascara

What is this sorcerery?

I've never used a Westman Atelier product and my first impression is I like the sleek red tube. It doesn't look like other mascara tubes imo. The mascara itself does have a scent so some people may be sensitive to that. It's one I associate with higher end products. Like they all smell similar. It doesn't bother me, but I definitely notice it. I don't feel the formula is as volumizing as they claim. I like thick dark lashes. It lengthen fine, nothing extraordinary there either. The clean...

Asian Lash-Type Approved

May have straight Asian lashes that point downwards. I have been using the Heroine Make Me mascara for almost half a decade until I developed a sensitivity to the ingredients. This change in sensitivity motivated me to use a mascara that has clean ingredients, can hold a curl and lengthen my lash type, doesn’t flake, smudge, or clump, and makes my lashes look sleek. I was never able to find a clean mascara that can accomplish ALL of these things for my lash type until now. I wore this...

AMAZING!

This mascara is super lightweight and natural looking, great for everyday wear. If you want to amp it up for evening you can definitely build it up. This mascara has NOT smudged or flaked at all after my 8 hour work shift. I definitely prefer this one over the other original Westman Atelier mascara. Overall I am super happy with this product and will buy again!

So good!

Absolutely love this mascara. It is natural looking but still packs a great punch. Doesn’t clump at all (her first did). Grabs every lash, so even my corners are covered. Without a doubt, it is my new go to.

I reach for this one almost every day

Probably the best brown mascara I've tried. I like how silky it feels when applying, and it doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes. The color is a nice deep brown but still noticeably brown instead of looking almost black. Great for a daily look and can be layered for extra oomph. Easily removes with warm water and/or face wash.

Great natural look but no volume as advertised.

This may be an unpopular opinion, but I’m going to be honest because I read reviews for honesty. Let’s start with the pros: great ingredients, great packaging, great applicator brush, great color. Cons: here is where I think if a mascara is labeled and marketed as lengthening + volumizing, I’m expecting just that. I felt it gave great natural look and looks far better than my naked lashes… but nothing I couldn’t achieve with any old mascara out there for far less than the price tag. The...

Disappointed with this mascara. I have straight eyelashes and have to use a curler. This mascara would weigh my lashes down and undo the curl. Additionally, it's very sticky and never seems to fully dry. If I put mascara on both my top and bottom lashes, I could feel them sticking together whenever I blinked, even at the end of the day.

TINY size for the 100 points gift

This review is for the 100 points gift with purchase. I can't believe I gave 100 points for a puny SAMPLE. This is outrageous.

least favorite mascara

The only redeeming factor about this mascara is the packaging, which is heavy and pretty. that said, I used this twice and couldn't bear to use it again, which is really upsetting. This product genuinely looks like there is nothing on my eye. I have blonde eyelashes, and this provides almost no pigment. my lashes are medium length and thickness, yet this does nothing to lift, define, or volumize. I figured I could use it for no makeup makeup looks, but i find it actually detracts from...

Clumpy and sticky

Third time buying this mascara. I bought black, then brown and now black again. The first two times the mascara was great, but this time around the formula is thick and clumpy. The brush puts on way too product on the lashes that it makes them clump together. I have to use an eyelash comb to get rid of excess and then I create marks on my lids. I wanted to love this product but unfortunately i'll be switching. Especially at this price point, the only nice thing is the sleek package but not...

Unfortunate Pass

It wasn’t horrible, there wasn’t any smudging which was what i was trying to avoid, it was a bit flaky though which was sad cause i wanted to love it

May repurchase

I could see this drying up quickly but I like the applicator and don’t find the formula clumping.