Brow Cheat Refillable Hair-Like Eyebrow Pencil

I really like the formula itself, the issue is that there’s almost NONE of it. The piece with the pencil part keeps falling out which honestly was a blessing in disguise because I saw how much product there actually was in it.

Horrible value for the price, not enough product

For $28 I’d expect an eyebrow pencil to last longer than 9 days. I’ve been using it daily just like a regular brow pencil, and today I come to find it’s already run out. It’s August 29th. I purchased it on August 20th. Absolutely ridiculous.

Bring back the refills!

I like this product which is why it gets two stars, but it's advertised as refillable, and the refills are ALWAYS out of stock. I've been on the waitlist for a year now, and the refill is not even offered at Sephora anymore. That was part of the reason I starting paying more for this eyebrow pencil, because of the refills. But it feels like false advertising.

My go to

I love this brow pencil. I wish there was more product in it for the high price. Remember to always put cap on otherwise it will dry out.

Staple Product

Nice applicator and is very pigmented. Dual end is very useful and pretty packaging. Would repurchase.

The price doesn’t match the quality.

Very small amount of product. There are many similar options with the same quality but more product for a lower price. The retractable mechanism causes the rest of the parts to loosen and come apart. The retractable mechanism causes the rest of the parts to loosen and come apart.

Solid eyebrow pencil. Long lasting, smudge proof and perfect shade match.

Go to brow pencil

I love this brow pencil! It goes on smooth and creamy. Definitely fills in my brows and gives good definition and look of volume. Has been lasting me awhile!

No more refills!!

This pencil gives me the BEST most natural looking eyebrows!! I’m sad the refills are no longer available making this product too expensive to replace every time I run out. Please bring back the refills!!!

Must-have eyebrow pencil

This eyebrow pencil is easy to use and gives hair-like strokes. Great color match for dark hair too!

Can do better

Personally not a fan, I felt like I was using a crayon to fill in my brows and it was not precise at all.

Won't buy again

I felt that the application felt hard and scratchy. Definitely used less expensive products that worked better.

Nice product. Glides on well and does the job! Use often.

Quality has gone down

I used to love this product but the last few orders have been defective - the pencil refill crumbles or the mechanism to twist the product up stops working after only a few applications. Sephora customer sevice was unable to issue a product replacement or credit for new product which was disappointing.

Perf shade!

OMG GET ITTT. I have been wanting to use an eyebrow pencile in my full face of makeup daily routine, I used to only use gel as it was so hard to find a shade that matched my hair. My hair color is light brown with golden blonde and a bit of ginger but I didn’t want to make my brows look lighter… but also not black dark where it looks like a joke… I love Charlotte tilbury as a brand so shopping for eyebrows means Charlotte tilbury! I was looking at which colors were for which shade and this...

Beware of actual colours and of 30 day ret.policy

So disappointed. The colour is very warm.Not as pic here.The Sephora in-store rep said CT tends to run warm. Wish I knew this before! Unable to ex as it was over 30days due to having surgery.

Usually love CT but…

Not this eyebrow pencil. Its very hard with a stiff, waxy formula. Formula tugs at the skin instad of gliding on. The lighter colors are all really warm, even the taupe. Stick to Benefit or ABH.

I spent my own money on this and love it

I do think this is better than all the other brow products I've tried, which really surprised me. I haven't had any issues with it breaking or falling out. I reach for this every day and see a marked difference when I use this vs any of my handful of other brow pencils. I love the taupe color or golden blonde color since I have blonde hair. Wish I could get a refill!!

No bad

Lasted 1 week pieces broke while using

Waste

The makeup immediately fell out of the stick onto the floor and got ruined this product is way too expensive for me to deal with this

Eyebrow pencil not worth what you pay for!

Pencil only lasted one month. Product not worth the money if you have to apply daily.

Not for the price!!

Alright. It you're going to be charging these kinds of prices for an eyebrow pencil, perhaps it shouldn't break on the second use. Ever since then, the black part on the pencil side falls out reliably every other time I use it. When it does so, you have to force it back into the pen, which would be fine, except it screws with the twist mechanism and so until you fidget with it for 5 min, it does not twist down only up. It's a real hassle and a reason I basically don't reach for it. Garbage...

Very little product provided.

Dont waste your money. Less expensive brands are just as good and give you more.

I love the colors they have but this pencil always falls out of the stick!!! Needs to be fixed asap and its always been like this

NO MORE REFILLS AVAILABLE!

You will fall in love with this product and sadly find out the refills are no longer available - which means you'll have to continue paying more to buy the full pencil.

Skeptic turned believer !

Ok BIG shout out to Aiden at the Vineland Pointe store in Orlando ! You were honest and I was a skeptic BUT I ❤️ this brow pencil ! I didn’t want to but I do and I THANK YOU!!🙏

Waste of Money

Unfortunately, when I opened the pencil part, it fell out and broke into several pieces. Also, it runs out super quick. Waste of money. Awful experience

My go to brow pencil

My go to brow pencil. Pen gives super realistic hair like strokes. The color I use does not look red which I find most brown pencils tend to do.

No more refills available

Love the product however the refill hasn’t been available for a while now. Not going to keep buying the full stick when refills are supposed to help.

A must have

Yes yes yes and yes. I love this product for my brows

Love love love

My go too ! Always and always ! I love the fact that you can’t order a refill!

wasteful

its breaks off very easily! I hardly do my brows daily and went through 2 pencils within a few months. waste of money. I use rare beauty pencil now

In my every day routine :)

✨I really love this product I use it almost every day I have adhd and it’s not to small but als fits in a bag so I can’t lose it✨

BEST EYEBROW PENCIL EVER - don't bother buying ...

Love this brow pencil - I purchased on 11/2/24 and began using on 11/3/24. It ran out on 12/5/24 so about 20 uses (I do not wear makeup daily) and Sephora DOES NOT sell the refills. You will have to either purchase from CT directly or buy a new one each month.

The Best!

This is my favorite brow pin. I've used all otger brands such as Anastasia, Urbandecay, Benifit, and Tarte. But this has been the best above all.

Love it

I usually use a gel or tinted gel but wanted a more natural look. Love the sharp end on this pencil and it looks great.

Breaks off

Every time I have used this the tip breaks off in pieces… waste of money :( 😞

Doesn’t last long. I had it for less than a month. Wouldn’t purchase again.

Eyebrow pencil 

Love love this product since it my eyebrows have been looking on point. I have a scar on one of my eyebrows, and this is the only product that has made my eyebrows look like new again and natural. 

Order online at your own risk

Mine arrived without the actual pencil. Sephora also didn't ship all my samples. Absolute nonsense.

Cheap packaging

I understand it’s refillable but the brow portion unscrews and falls out easily. It’s flimsy and you have to keep pushing it back in to keep it secure. Also you can see how little product you get…about a 3/4 inch. Will not purchase again.

Dry

Not awesome at all. The crayon stick part of it broke off after a month. Very dry formula and does not easily glide on…

Best of the best!

Beautiful packaging and great this was great for a natural look. This is a new favorite.

Pencil Breaks Too Easily

The pencil breaks so easily! It’s on the dry side so you have to put some pressure to get color, but if you go too hard, it snaps right off. I prefer the old version.

My favorite brow product!

I've used lot's of brow products (nyx, Anastasia, Tarte, etc) and this is hands down the best product so far. it's small and angled which makes for easy applications. the consistency is like butter so it glides on and can be brushed out to look natural very easily. the color selection is also great. Definitely recommend!

Bad product

The brow pencil crumbles as you apply it to your eyebrows

Best eyebrow pencil I’ve tried! Goes on and blends in perfectly.

Best Pencil, hands down!

This is always in included in my makeup routine! I’ve tried so many others, but none compare to the Brow Cheat!

No Red Undertone! ⭐️

So far, I love this. NO RED UNDERTONE! And that is exactly what I was looking for. I also did my research before purchasing this brow pencil & it was listed as the #1 brow pencil on a trusted site. Love it!

Questionable

Trying to understand why this all of a sudden Cara Perplexed as to why all of a sudden this cannot be seems a little strange this can no longer be shipped to the U.S. when you can order it from Nordstrom which I just did

Missing refills

I have had a few of these pencils over the years & they are on par w/ every other brand I've tried, nothing special. I wanted it bc I liked the idea of being able to refill it but I have not been able to find refills for months so now I just have a bunch of empty pencils, which defeats the purpose :/

Beautiful long lasting brows

Love this pencil! My brows look great and it lasts all day! Beautiful application and it glides on easily. My one disappointment is that it only lasted a month. There is not very much product inside. I'm used to my brow pencils lasting much much longer. For the price I expected more product.

Long lasting must have

I have extremely dry sensitive acne prone skin and I am also allergic to a common preservative found in a ton of makeup - thankfully this brow pencil checked all the boxes. Huge plus - It is long lasting! the hot humid

Highly recommend

Beautiful application, glides on easily and precisely. Lasts all day, and really love the fact you can buy refills to save money.

Great brow product

Great color, fairly long lasting. Easily blends, looks natural. Use a light hand and you'll be fine!

Love it!

This has become a new favorite in my makeup bag. I LOVE how this gives a flattering shape to my brows and yet allows them to look really natural at the same time. I went for the 'Black brown' shade, which turned out to be a perfect match. To apply, I first brush my eyebrows up, and then apply the pen in an upwards motion, following the direction of brow growth. The formula is like a wax and it's very pigmented, so it's best to apply with a light hand. You also don't need a lot of product as...

Holy grail

I've tried almost every brow pencil over the years and always made my way back to Benefit microbrow until now! I bought this on a whim and I'm so glad I did because it's my HG eyebrow pencil now.

Great for blondes

Finding a good pencil for a blonde with very light brown eyebrows is hard; many of them tinge red which doesn’t work for my ashy color. This one is great and it has a nice spool on the end to brush the brows.

Nope! Save your coin!

I was pretty disappointed with this product considering how much I paid for it. The color ended up being a bit too warm for me, bit the thing that really dissatisfied me was that it smeared a lot. Save your coin!

Can purchase refills

one of my favorite brow pencils! you can purchase additional refills to save money, builds and glides on smoothly. also, lasts me all day! would recommend.

Best brow pencil

Best brow liner- goes on smooth and long lasting. Only downside is that it runs out faster than the benefit liner but perhaps it’s because the texture is smoother. Love it has a refill option.

My favorite pencil but…

But I wish yall sold the refills…especially in store :/

Not for me

I found it broke too easily. The color, taupe, was perfect! I would not buy again, unless you thicken it up a bit.

I probably won't buy it again

It breaks too easily. I applied only light pressure and it broke! It needs to be thicker.

Great color

I love this pencil and color range for me (dark blonde with light brows). May taupes and blonde shades have too much red in them and this one skews ash. Only complaint is eventually the pencil/stick falls out and it’s no longer usable.

Not worth it. Would be $5

Very disappointed in this product. I purchased it a little over a week ago and the product is gone. Decided to open it to see why it wasted so quickly- it’s because there’s barely any product not worth the price 20

Love it but one thing is…

My new favorite brow pencil! The packaging and overall style of the pencil is perfect & luxurious. The product glides on smooth and is pigmented just enough but still buildable and will stay on all day! *Only thing is since it is refillable, that part pops off sometimes when i take the cap off but other than that it’s my new favorite!

I loved the product itself it was super hydrated and a smooth application! However, the makeup got stuck at the bottom of the tube and then it fell out and I could not get it back! I was a little disappointed

Best Brow pencil ever

I HAVE TRIED IT ALL AND THIS BY FAR HAS BEEN MY FAVORITE ALREADY ON MY SECOND ONE !

Great product

Excited to see ulta carries this brand now, but disappointed they dont offer refills for the brow pencil. Guess I won't be buying them here after all...

Product quality not the same

This is not the same formula as before. I waited forever for this to come back in stock and now, ugh. …Something’s going on with this line. Seems like they all downshift the quality of their products after a period of time.

This pencil glides over skin with ease. No tugging. Beautiful and precise. Removes easily with makeup remover. Love that you can purchase refills! Wish the spoolie brush on end was fuller though.

Best one yet

Been using this Charlotte Tibury hair-like eyebrow pencil for years and it is super easy to apply. I believe the variety of colors makes it easier to chose the right tone.

I love this product! It’s soft enough and pigmented, perfect for my face ❤️

This has become a new favorite in my makeup bag. I already have pretty dark eyebrows, so I can sometimes do without a brow product, but I just loved how this gave a nice shape to my brows and makes them look really natural at the same time. I went for the 'Black brown' shade and think it was a perfect match. To apply, I first brush my eyebrows up, and then apply the pen in an upwards motion, following the direction of brow growth. The formula is wax and it's really pigmented so it's best to...

This is so smooth when applying and precise. I love that it blends and stays put.

Brow Cheat (Natural Brown)

Love the concept of this being a refillable brow pencil. I got this in the shade natural brown and it is the perfect colour for dark-coloured hair. I use this to fill in the sparse areas of my brows and it also has a natural powder-like finish. Although I cannot mimic my little brow hairs with this pencil as it does not give me as much precision as the kosas brow pop nano or anastasia brow wiz (both I love very much), this is easier to use when you’re on the go and just need something to...

Moving on

I’ve been using for a few years now and have finally moved on to Merit’s brow gel. This has a great selection of shades (love cool vs warm options for hair products). I love the shape of this product and the refill option. However, the value just isn’t there for the cost and I’ve had many break, which is then a pain to try to use up all the remaining product. They only tend to last me about 2 months, and I use every other day at most. At this point it’s like a bad boyfriend I’m just not...

A joke

Insanely small amount. How is this so expensive for such little product? Should have returned it when I could…

Holy grail for dark skin, oily, sparse hair

I’ve used this product faithfully for the last two years. As a dark skin black woman with genetically thin and sparse eyebrow hair, this product has been my holy grail. It’s a better consistency than the NYX micro eyebrow pencil (for me it’s too chalky and ashy on my skin) and better than the ABH ultra slim eyebrow pencil (great shade range but not friendly for my oily skin). This product can give me depth, dimension, and color. I’ve had people tell me they never knew my brows were drawn in....

Yes buy it

The perfect colour. Stays all day. Easy to do a precise brow

Not long lasting

Love the way it goes on and looks great… for about 10 minutes. I have given it so many chances and it continues to be disappointing. It smudges and sweats off easily. Any heat or moisture and it’s gone. Ends up looking patchy

Great but Could be Better

Okay, so I’m coming from using a competing brow pencil that’s got a finer tip, and there’s a definite learning curve to the triangle shape here, but once you adjust it’s great. My only real complaint is that both lids, for the spoolie & pencil, are perfectly round and LOVE to roll away. I really wish they’d angled at least part of each slightly so they’d stay put while using this product.

Great color -not so great product.

Aside from the color, which is my perfect summer shade, the product was very dry. It crumbled multiple times. I’m used to this product just gliding on. I bought the darker color up and the same thing. It was dry and crumbly. I was so disappointed.

ABSOLUTE NEED

this product is perfect. i’m blonde, and i thought it may be too dark. it’s not! it’s amazing. you need this!

Good product with 1 small but significant flaw

My current go-to for my dark, but sparse, brows. It does the job and fills in nicely. Color is nice and highly pigmented. I only took 1 star off because it does tend to transfer to your fingers, etc

Must buy it!

It’s the perfect shape to fill in the sparse areas of my brows with no problem! I’m kind of obsessed with it and I am so happy it’s refillable. The price is actually not bad if you compare to other brands.

Love this

My second purchase. Stays on all day and doesn’t travel or smear. Use a lighter touch than you think you need; it’s a really great product. Not sure how it’s refillable though; I think when I went to restock, buying a whole new pencil was the only option. Had no idea it was refillable.

Not worth it

It broke like 5 minutes after I received it, it’s expensive and super fragile

Refilled, multiple times

Best hairlike pencil ever. Stays on through sweat and rain. If I forget to clean it off, it’ll stay on for a few days even!

it's good

It's a very nice brow pencil. Looks natural. It's small enough to create hair like strokes. Not creamy nor dry. It's the perfect texture.

I don't get the hype

Not sure why everyone is raving about this. I find that it's not nearly as microfine as any of the other pencils I've used. The Hourglass, Patrick Ta, and even Anastasia. Not only does that make it hard to draw microfine hairs, but it's harder and waxier, and I can't seem to get my brows to look the way I want them to. The end of the pencil always pops off for me and I'm stuck screwing it back in. Maybe got a dud. The only redeeming quality was the undertones being cool/neutral and the...

I can do without it

This pencil was dark brown but it went on very light and it didn’t stay on thanks I’ll keep my Anastasia

Good but...

Love it!!! It's pretty pigmented and forgiving, I can easily smudge off a stroke that might look weird. 3 stars because I can't tell if this or the ABH Brow Freeze is making me lose a few brow hairs. :/

Didn’t last long

Loved how the pencil glided on beautifully and made my eyebrows look amazing. With that being said, I give it only 2 stars because it only lasted a few weeks. For that price, it should last way longer than that.

Expensive but nice.

I love the fact that the Black Brown shade is not too warm and not too grey. It’s just a very natural tone on my caramel complexion. I like that it’s refillable. Pricey but I get compliments on my brows when I use it.

Lasted exactly 2 weeks?!?

Great product, impressive number of shades. I’m writing this on day 20 of owning this product and it’s completely gone- and I don’t even wear makeup every day! I will not purchase again.

Seamless brows

Very similar to the Benefit brow pencil but I like this rougher finer spooly better! The liner piece is a smooth formula and has small tip to draw brow hairs. I use the Benefit 24hr gel after I use this and it's the best!

LOVE!

There is alot of cheaper eyebrow pencils out there but this one is definitely worth the$.this is a very quick and easy to use product and blendable if you are looking for an ombre brow or even a light colour under a fluffy brow

Love this pencil

Love it!!! Stays on all day and no smudging at all…Color is perfect also…Will definitely buy again…

I haven’t been using this long but I really like it so far. Perfect match for me and I like the angled tip. I think I’m the long run it’s easier to replace just the tip as well.

Only lasted 2 weeks

Absolutely LOVED this product until it was empty after 2 weeks… for the price point that’s just not enough for me. $15 a week on brows? No thanks!

My daily routine wouldn't be complete without it!

As soon as I tried this pencil, I couldn't use anything else since it was so easy to blend and stayed on all day. This purchase has exceeded my expectations!

Bad production

It works great but when I bought it the pencil was broken, so I exchanged it and the new one I bought was broken too...

Best Light Blonde pencil!

I'm a natural blonde with very cool light blonde hair and my eyebrows are super light, so it's hard for me to find a brow pencil that doesn't come off too red or brown. I've been using ABH and Benefit just in Taupe, which is fine and a better option than their lighter options which come off more reddish. This pencil in light blonde, perfection! It's the perfect shade for light blonde hair. I love the ease of the application, you can go light or build up. I think I will be forever using Brow...

refillable is the best!

I love refillable products and I love this pencil. my only grievance is it runs out quicker than I’d like, but that doesn’t stop me from repurchasing

Not worth the cost

So disappointed, this was my second refill, and they do not last long at all! I took apart the refill and found there is a large quantity still in there, but there’s no way to use it unless you pull the whole thing apart!!!

My Favorite Brow Pencil

This is a perfect color for my light eyebrows, not too red or too taupe. The consistency is perfect to make small strokes to fill in my thin brows. I have Benefit and Anastasia as well. But I reach for this one because of the color and ease of use.

This is an excellent product. It's easy to use and does as promised. I ordered a shade too light, but am able to layer it without looking overdone. That's a big plus!

I like it

I have super dark brows and light skin; this shade is great for me and it lasts all day. Very fine tip that doesn’t smear or break. Looks very natural.

It’s an absolute no.

Literally got this delivered on Monday 10/17, and as of 10/20(!!) pencil is empty. Was extremely dry and difficult to use. Waste of money tbh.

I like the quality and the color and the softness of the pencil, but unfortunately, after using about a month, it broke!! I lose my money

Natural look

This stuff is really good, long lasting and gives a natural look.

needs a reboot

I usually love all my Tilbury purchases, not thrilled with this one. Pencil is so thin, it breaks with almost every use, no matter how lightly I press or how short I twist it out…I gave it two stars because I like being able to twist instead of sharpening and I like the brush on the other end.

this brow pencil is so creamy, and lasts all day (and night). love love love this product.

love there is a refill option

Glad there is a refill for the brow cheat. This is the refill and it is the same size of what is in the full size when you buy it, I actually measured it. It was very easy to swap out the refill. Very easy to use, fills in brows quickly and easily and stays put the whole day.

sensational

This pencil just glides on! So creamy and long lasting. Barely any transfer at all and the pigment truly mimics my hair! I also think the formula is great for hair growth. Highly recommend

Simply the best brow pencil I own. I would be willing to say it’s even better than benefit which has had a monopoly on brows for forever.

The pencil fell out and I barely even used it. Very disappointed. I liked the product but waste of money due to the design.

Love it. On my 3rd refill.

This is an excellent product. To those that didn’t get the memo and left complaints about its size - it’s a REFILL for a full sizes eyebrow pencil. Hello.

Thumbs up! My fav brow product for light filling in. I continue to repurchase.

Like it a lot, used benefit before but this brow pencil match my eyebrows colour better. Will definitely repurchase, looks very natural

It filled the eyebrows beautifully and has a really nice tip for precision. Also the colour is prefect for my faded black brows.

smart choice

You save money and makes less waste. Which is a win in my book. I love this product and am happy to see refillable rather then my having to buy a another whole stick when I already have one

Buyer Beware

I used this pencil once. It came apart as I was using it. I had to throw it out. Waste of money!

Cover/smudge/soft/expensive and very tiny

Got it without a cover and it wasn’t a good product. Easy smudge all over my eye brows and for the price I pay for a very tiny eye brow product not really worth it. Will not buy it again and I do not recommend it.

Love that it’s refillable. Great product. Typically lasts about 3 months with daily use. Great control which allows for more precise application. Rich texture which allows for more vibrant colour and a gentler application.

Just a Really Good Brow Pencil

This is product that I honestly can’t believe I’ve been missing out on this long. For years I’ve tried different brands, all decent, but with having brows that are only sparse at the ends - this product is so natural with matching the rest of my natural hairs. Now my go to pencil, I highly recommend. Also, this product can go on as light / dark as you want it with easy control.

Soft brown is a perfect shade for redheads! I’ve spent far too much time and far too much money on brow products that are either vibrant orange or just regular brown. Brow cheat is perfect and looks natural!

wish it was more hair like

I like the shape of this pencil and the fact that it's refillable. However, the consistency doesn't work for me. it's way too soft for my liking - more like an eyeliner consistency - so it is not 'hair like' at all. The spoolie at the end is also a little short.

My new holy grail brow pencil! It has a precise tip for all your brow dreams. This pencil goes on smoother then anything I’ve ever used. I thought that I would be a brow wiz forever kind of girl, however that has now changed. It’s even refillable!!! Thanks, CT for doing IT…again!!

Didn’t last 2 months

Didn’t last 2 months and I don’t do my makeup every day. I couldn’t believe it when the tiny last bit fell out on my face this morning. Will not purchase again. Disappointed as I have been with other CT products

I never thought I’d stop using benefit brow products. This makes the finest lines and blends so easily. I can make very natural looking brows out of almost nothing.

Not for me.

Nothing special about this for me. I’m not a fan of the angle application, if you’re looking for more precise placement I would not recommend this eye brow pencil. I won’t be repurchasing.

solid product but overpriced

Generally, I like this product but I’m not sure it’s worth the price. I’ve bought comparable products at the drugstore for half the price. Also, I’m not sure the description of it providing a “precise” like is accurate. It’s too thick to be precise. It’s more of a typical pencil but with a little waxier/smoother formula.

I love this product with my whole heart !!! It’s so creamy it makes my eyebrows looked so snatched and the colour just blends so well. I highly suggest if you’re looking for a creamy and easy to blend eyebrow pencil !

it’s a no for me

I found this to be so dry.. I’ve used way cheaper pencils that work way better than this. Plus I was expecting a fine tip but this is just a smaller triangular shapes pencil, very disappointed

Best Eyebrow Pencil ever. Easy to apply and works great for covering eyebrow scars.

Must have

I get a lot of compliments on my brows when I use this. Color is also a perfect match.

Great Eyebrow Pencil

The best eyebrow pencil that I ever had. It glides very smoothly.

I love the density of the eyebrow, easy to apply. And the color really match my skin

Little to no product!

This literally lasted less than a month???? I have very full brows that need just a bit of filling in sparse spots, so for this to last less than a month is shocking? Only gave it 2 stars instead on 1 because it is a good product but what the heck will not purchases again?!

this pencil does what it’s supposed to, it blends very easily but the spoolie is definitely harder compared to ABH ones.

Fail

Lasted less than a month because a bit of the tip breaks off every other use. Does not deposit color evenly and takes several passes before you would get any color out. 1 star for the nice ashy taupe.

Overpriced and it kept falling out . Benefit or ABH are better IMO.

Smudges easily, not quite as precise as some other brow pencils out there. Otherwise a solid choice. Good colour.

Love this brow cheat for precision shaping!

This brow cheat is fantastic for enhancing sparse brow areas and comes in great selection of shades. I love the precision it provides for adding brow hairs just where needed. Always have one with me. They are refillable which is great and cost saving. I really like the small yet firm spoolie on the other end that really grabs the brow hair. Highly recommend!

not worth the $$

The amount of product did not last long and the casing fell apart at one point. For $25 I was expecting perfection. I would not buy again.

Very little product - didn't last

Really disappointed with this - the product itself looks great and easily applied, the only problem is that it doesn't last. It ran out after 1 month, which indicates very little product. Such a shame, if there was more product I would 100% rebuy.

not worth it !

Tried it thinking as it was probably the most expensive I have bought, but sadly it seems to have dried out of something as when I apply it , hardly makes a mark on my brow ? Like to return but not sure how as was a waste of money :0(

Best Eyebrow Pencil ever!

Absolutely love this pencil! I’ve been using it now for a few months and it still gives me small hair like strokes. It looks natural and fills in my brows perfectly. Also a huge bonus that it’s refillable.

Fav brow pencil. I’ve tried brow wiz, good proof and precisely by benefit and this is by far the best. I love the fact that it’s refillable so packaging waste can be reduced. After time, this product will also be cheaper as you’ll only have to by the refill.

All about the natural look

Product is Aces! however..the material that the pencil is made and the brush could do a lot better (they cheap). Brush is so harsh, comparing to the Anastasia 7B. I got the "natural brown", it´s the perfect match for my brows! I have warm skin tone, fair with yellow undertones. My eyebrows are almost black..BUT I'm so happy I did not got a darker tone because it would've only made my facial features look so intense and less natural.

The Great One!!!!

Natural look. Non waxy. Doesn't transfer, move around or smear. Such a great product!!! I am sold and will be using the refills as I go through this one. I have tried so many high end and drugstore products and have finally found the one I will stick with!!

the perfect combo !!! Love.

Love this eyebrow pencil, it’s perfect for making those thin strokes because the tip is much more durable and sturdy than other brow pencils I’ve used. It’s a perfect in between of Anastasia Beverly Hills’ two sizing options in offered, which I find to be too thick or just way too thin…! LOVE

Perfect!!

NEW HG PRODUCT FOR ME!!! It’s amazing! The color payoff is great & I don’t feel like I have to drag it with force across my brows & skin just to get it to show up. Fills and lines my brows perfectly & I’ve also never had a problem with it fading or transferring! LOVELOVELOVE

I don’t think I’ve ever experience a product exceeding my expectations like this one

I love this product so much and I will recommend this to my friends.

Great eyebrow pencil for precision

Really like this pencil for outlining my brows. It’s really thin which is great for precise coverage that looks more realistic

Meeh…. Not the best and doesn’t live up to the hype. Like the fact that it’s refillable but not sure when it will finish as I don’t feel like using it

Worst pencil ever. Sephora brand is way better than this. Doesn’t last long, replacement head keep coming out

Really like this brow pencil got precision and nice full looking brows. I might like this better than Anastasias

Wooow

Love the size of this product! Perfect for beginners!! It helps you not to overdo your eyebrows. It looks natural. Amazing!!

You will use lots of refills!

I love the color and I like its lasting power; however, the pencil tip breaks plus it only lasts a couple months! I have never gone through a pencil this fast! I also like the fact that it is refillable, however you go through so much packaging to have the refills shipped that it cancels out the refillable pencil!

I am someone who has no idea how to properly fill in their eyebrows and even I have been able to make my blonde eyebrows look amazing and full using this pencil. It is idiot proof.

The replacements are too little.

Nice packaging, however Anastasia Beverly Hills works and lasts longer on me. The replacements are too little.

Really not worth the money. Definitely won’t be repurchasing. It isn’t smooth to go on and doesn’t show up the way I would like. There is no way to create actual hair like strokes with this product.

Doesn't last long

I liked the color of this and the spoolie brush on the end was nice, but I felt like I had hardly used this pencil and then it was all gone! I will be switching because I felt like it was not a very good value and I don't want to have to keep repurchasing every month.

Can’t find the right color. Too dark

My color by PUR blonde roast was discontinued. All the taupess and blondes are either too light or most have an ashy, dark tinge, instead of a warm blonde tone. The right color for silver hair and light skin is hard to find, without looking dirty. Also eyebrows are extremely thin, so I am depending in the color itself.

Love this eyebrow pencil! I've always had a hard time doing my brows, I'd end up looking like an angry cartoon character half the time. This brow pencil makes it so much easier! It doesn't make thick lines so it's easy to feather in some colour at the beginning of the brow and it softens beautifully when you use the brush on it.

Great!

I have used Anastasia micro pencil for years but wanted to try CT bc I’ve heard good things about it. I LOVE it! The shade matches perfectly and goes in way better and blends nicely. Same price I think and packaging is beautiful!

Like this pencil quite a bit. Easy to draw hair like lines, stays on well throughout the day . Brush is quite good. Plan to purchase again

A must purchase for your eyebrows!

[Employee of sephora] I am in LOVE. I usually use benefit for my eyebrows now I’m conflicted. This pencil is so creamy and so easy to apply. It lasts all day. It literally makes it so natural looking it’s insane. I also recommended getting her brow gel to lock it in.

Best color options of any brow filler pencils. What's especially terrific about this product is the REFILL option. This way I end up will much less plastic waste and it's less expensive too.

I like the fact that the tip is think and it applies smooth and even

New fav brow pencil

I’m not one who prefers a brow pencil because i have such full brows, but when I tried this product, I ended up really enjoying it. It is a teardrop/triangular shape, which some people do not like. But it is SO FINE that you can truly create beautifully perfect hairlike texture with it. It’s the perfect shape to fill in the sparse areas of my brows with no problem! I’m kind of obsessed with it and I am so happy it’s refillable. The price is actually not bad if you compare to other brands....

Good thing it's refillable because this pencil does not last AT ALL. I have had this pencil for less than a month and between it breaking off every other use and just being so dry and crumbly, it's already empty! I honestly wish I just stuck with my Benefit Goof Proof, because those pencils last me almost 6 months with every day use! Will definitely not buy again.

The product is good but I did not receive my sample products.

Solid brow product; best of all is that it refills

This is a good brow product. Nothing spectacular to me. I wish it have sparse brows more of a waxy, fluffy brow texture that you could build up which looks a little more natural but that’s a personal preference. All in all, creates a good brow. Packaging is lovely and best of all, it’s refillable which is why I switched in the first place.

Goes on smoothly

This is a great brow pencil. It has a fine slanted end that makes it easy to get precision strokes. It looks natural, doesn't smudge and stays on all day. It's a bit pricey so I deducted a star but you can buy refills for it so that makes it worth the price.

Convenient!

Love the ability to purchase a refill!! Makes using a product like this worthwhile!

I just needed something subtle to make my eyebrows look a tiny bit fuller at the ends. This works really well and goes on nicely for a very natural look.

Love this pencil. The color. The formula. Looks natural and lasts all day.

Brows Baby

Great color match and coverage. Skinny enough to get brow hair strokes. Due to being skinny, I does break easily, so be careful.

Love it!

I received this product for free to try and give my review. I am absolutely obsessed with this product!!! It works so incredibly well. The spooly is perfect and the color matches my brow perfectly. I would highly recommend this product to anyone trying to perfect their brows. I will definitely be purchasing again.

Amazing

Loved it. Received complimentary. Works really great!!!

I quite liked this eyebrow pencil! It’s soft and pigmented and I love that is has the handle little brush on the other end!

I absolutely love this brow hair-like eyebrow pencil. it has smaller triangular shape then the brow lift for a more precise shaper. I highly recommend this for a beginner like me.

The most precise option

Amazing! I’m used to filling in my brows with a standard size eye pencil and the size of the ct brow cheat tip is unmatched. I was able to get incredibly precise strokes in, making for the most natural look. The black brown color also blended with my hair perfectly. I don’t think I can ever go back.

My supermodel Brows

I love how easy this brow pencil is to use. The color matches my brows perfectly. I can draw them in thick or thin depending on my makeup look for the day.

Subtle color, easy to use

The packaging is lovely, and the twisting mechanics to raise the wee brush are smooth. The color is subtle. I do not, however, usually need a filler like this. I received it as a sample for my honest review, and it would be a great product for those who use such brow stuff. (In the photo, this one is in the middle.)

Brow Cheat

I received this product for free in exchange for an honest review. I have natural blonde brows but dye my hair black. This makes concealing my eyebrows natural color a bit challenging. I did like this more of a brow liner personally. It was easy to use and glides on smoothly. I lined the brows and added some of the hair like strokes. I was given the entire set and will say that I find that if used all together, it’s an amazing product! If you don’t need a lot of extra coverage, this would be...

Love it!

I received this product free for reviewing purposes from Influenster. I have really loved using this! It fills in my brows very well. I have dark brows but they are sparse so this makes them noticeable.

Super easy to apply, so smooth

I am an Anastasia brow girl by default, so that is what I'm comparing this to. Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat is incredibly easy to aply. Very little pressure is needed to create feather like strokes. The color is a great match. I only give it four stars, because it doesn't last quite as long as Anastasia does.

Love it

Love the natural brown it’s that perfect brown color, the tip is very thin and so easy to create those hair strocks plus is soft enough to to where I don’t feel like I am scratching my skin compared to other ones, love it !!!

I have eyebrows now!

I love this product! The color range & match is perfect for my dark but not black hairs. Application is so easy and the precision is amazing to get the hair-like strokes. The ends/tails of my eyebrows exist now and they don’t look painted on at all. It also lasted all day after sweating in the heat!

The Brow Cheat is a perfect name for this product. It makes filling in my eyebrows so easy. The color is a great match to my natural brows.

love!

absolutely love this! as an brow wiz girl, this was definitely a great alternative!! and eyebrow pencils are a hard formula to get down. love the color, love how sturdy the actually brush/pen is. i’ve had issues with my ABH one breaking and i did not have that problem here. i did receive this complimentary, but i am officially a convert!

The best!

By far one of my favorites! I love how slim the product is and it glides on super easy!

So happy I found a refillable pencil without breaking the bank. A little goes a long away so it’s money well spent for a CT product. Make sure to set it with clear gel or setting spray, otherwise it can come off pretty easily

My insert keeps coming off and the product itself is so fragile it breaks off when I’m trying to use it. And I’m not applying a lot of pressure

Awesome shape and color payoff

I am a victim of the over-plucked eyebrow trend from 20 years ago. My eyebrows are very thin and do not grow in anymore. I have to use product to fill them in. This product was really good. It has great color pay off. I love the shape of the micro pencil. It’s like a micro triangle shape. You can use the tip of the triangle for hair like strokes and it’s a thicker part of the tip for filling in. Definitely makes for precision. The best part of this product is that it makes filling in your...

I had to do a couple of strokes on my hand to get it to start drawing but after that, it worked great. I have a little spot on my right eyebrow where no hair grows so the thinness of the Brow Cheat is perfect for drawing in little hairs and filling in smaller areas that need it

I like this product for adding some microblading illusion to my brows. Goes on smooth and looks great.

Amazing coverage

My eyebrows are greying and this makes it so I have eye brows that are all one color. Lifesaver!!!

Great product

I really the Brow Cheat pencil and it's nice to be able to get a refill that costs less than the buying the entire pencil. It glides on smoother than any other pencil and lasts all day.

This system is a dream!

The precision brush is bushy and works well to lift the brow hairs and find your shape and the pencil tip helps draw and define added depth and volume to your natural brow shape without looking too heavy. Along with other products from this line it creates a natural and beautiful brow for any person. Highly recommend!

Great brow product! Love the color and precision. Packaging is beautiful as always with CT

I really liked this brow pencil! The color is great- very natural. I have dark copper hair and the brown was very warm so it matched well. Also the pencil has an angle to it so it makes applying super easy!

Great brow pencil

I really love this brow pencil. It has staying power but is also workable to get the strokes looking as natural as possible. I can draw on my fine hairs with it as well as fill in certain areas with more pigment.

This is so good! Goes on so easily. Color is fantastic and is officially my new brow liner

easy to use, overpriced

goes on easily, long lasting, but over priced for what you get

Fine Tunes Brows

Brow Cheat can aid in forming those hair-like strokes. It’s a super fine tip with light color that fills in gaps without looking too heavy. (Hello fellow stomach sleepers - you know what the gappy brow can looks like).

This is one of the best eyebrow pencils I have used. The formula is not too soft or stiff. It allows me to draw on the perfect amount. The shade is also perfect and blends into my natural hairs perfectly. I tend to get oily in my T-zone but doesn’t breakdown at the end of the day. I also like the thin tip, which allows me to draw on realistic hairs.

The one that got me to switch!

I LOVE this eyebrow pencil! I had been using hourglass for over 8 years and this is the one that finally got me to switch! Long lasting and very precise for natural brows.

Love love love!

I’m a huge fan of the Charlotte Tilbury make up so I was super excited to to try out this eyebrow pencil and it did not them disappoint! The shade is a perfect match to my natural eyebrows, the application is amazing and I love the way my eyebrows look! Highly recommended!

Great product

I loved this product so much. I received it for free in exchange for my review. I am so new to “doing eyebrows” but it was super easy and didn’t make me look too dark. I would highly recommend for ease of use and color matching

I love this brow pencil. Easy to draw, doesn’t smudge, I like the fine tip, I can mimic the natural brow.

Fantastic pencil. Soft enough for me but doesn’t break easily as I am heavy handed. Love that I can just get refills. My new go to.

Amazing

This is hands down my favorite eyebrow pencil take it from someone who owns more makeup than I would Like to admit and also has tried has every brow product on the market it's really that good... I love it and I haven't stopped using it since I received it!! These brow products are amazing!!! #supermodelbrow #contest #complimentary @Influenster @ctilburymakeup

I love love how thin this pencil is! It really allows you to shape how you want it and to build up to what you like .. it really makes it look natural and lasts a long time !

Love how thin this pencil is for precision

This pencil goes on smooth and fluffs out with the spooly really nicely. I also love the thin, wedge shape of the pencil. I’m kind of in between colors so using the black brown is a little bold for me, but I still like it. It doesn’t wear of wipe off throughout the day. It leaves my brows looking great from start to finish.

Love this eyebrow pencil! It’s easy to use doesn’t clump and it looks so natural. Doesn’t smudge which it’s important!

Love

Been using this every day since I received it , brows are truly the architecture of the face . I love how it looks and the finish . The application is easy . This is a wonderful product

The best!!!

So in love with this brow pencil, leave my brows amazing! Super smooth and super pigmented I really like how my eyebrows look!

new staple!

I used to only use Brow Wiz but this is my new favorite. I like that with the refill I can buy a different shade (I go between taupe and natural brown depending on my hair color). I also love that it doesn’t smudge even after a long day which would sometimes happen with Brow Wiz. One cartridge lasted me about 2 and a half months with almost daily use. The refill was easy to change too. Overall super happy with it and love the movement towards less waste!!!

Highly recommend!

Easy to use! I will buy this product again! It really feels great on and stays on until you take it off.

Love this. The selection of shades is great. It lasts all day. Very easy to apply and natural looking. I keep just a tiny bit of the tip visible and it’s never broken. I’ve recommended it to friends and family and they love it too. Happy that it’s refillable and hope that all companies achieve that goal.

I really like the spoolie and the wedge shaped pencil. It makes really good natural strokes and with brow gel, stays forever

Yes yes yes

For starters, my go to is usually elf eyebrow for the functionality and price. However it kinda just fills and shapes. This pencil really gave a more dramatic effect. It took me a couple tries but now i really figured out how to mimic hair and make my eyebrows look more full. Additionally, my normal elf brush ens is way more soft and fluffy. This was is crazy stuff- in a good way. Really helps fix the hairs and create a cohesive look. If i have to time (5-10 min) to really do my brows, this...

I love this better than the Benefit precisely!!!

I love this better than the Benefit precisely!!! I don’t really like to change up my makeup products especially if I love them and they work for me.. but, I decided to take a chance and buy the Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat pencil, and I’m IN LOVE! I love this way more than the Benefit... and the Benefit is my go-to. So that says a lot! And I have sparse brows so I was worried this would make my eyebrows look to blocky but it didn’t! So natural. In love!

Excellent product! Will be buying again, works great

Foolproof

So foolproof and easy to use! Really blends in and gives you the perfect brows each time!

I received this product as a complimentary sample to try. This eye brown pencil is easy to use and I love the fact that it’s refillable!

I actually found this product hard to use because it’s so thick yet angled and I’m afraid it’s going to break off with too much pressure. I prefer the smaller pencil style but it pairs well with the gel.

This product is very nice. I like that it’s light and easy to blend out. It doesn’t create harsh lines and fills nicely. Oh pairs really well with the brow gel. I also like the small spoolie brush attached.

Great Product

A sephora employee recommended this product to me and it’s honestly so easy to work with and matches me perfectly.

Step up your brow game

This product single handed has made me FINALLY put down my Benefit brow products. I love that it is refillable which really helps the environment as well. The angle of the tip makes it so easy to use and that bristle brush on the other side makes brushing the hair in place a breeze! Worth every penny.

Good Texture, BUT…

I did fall in love with the texture of this product very quickly; it’s VERY easy to apply and never looks too heavy. That being said, I find it has a tendency to transfer to the skin above my brows throughout the day even if I’m not touching them. I love the idea of the refills but they run out FAST. I do my eyebrows almost every day and had to repurchase a refill after 3 weeks. I’ll be going back to my Anastasia Brow Wiz because as much as I love the product itself, I’ve never dealt with...

I received this in exchange for a review, and I actually really love it. The pencil tip is narrow, but not flimsy. And the shade is perfect. It's dark enough to blend with my brow, but not so dark it looks odd with my bleached hair.

Great for filling in

I received this product for free in exchange for my honest review. I have a naturally dark brown hair which is colored to a light brown color now. My brows are very dark, so I chose the soft brown color to coordinate. I like that this pencil is very sharp on the end. It is great for getting an area in my brow which has a scar, and I’m able to cover it easily. I like brow pencils that have spoolies on the end, So this one fit the bill. I found that the pencil was easy to apply, blended very...

Natural looking brows!

I received the Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat Refillable Hair-Like Eyebrow Pencil complimentary from Influenster. I was worried about the color being too dark for my brows, but I was pleasantly surprised. This eyebrow pencil goes on smoothly and creates a very natural brow look. I love the wand that is on the opposite end of the brow pencil. It helps to smooth hairs out of place and create a more defined, clean brow look. It is easy to use and I would absolutely buy it!

Thin pencil for thin brows!! I absolutely love this! It’s creamy and micro! I have thin brows and it works so well

Perfect!!

I always wanted to have beautiful eyebrows and Am completely scared to do a permanent one and regret!, with this product I could have my dream eyebrow and I am not a professional of the make up, this product gives you a self confidence because makes a big difference in your look!!

I LOVE IT

Omg im so obsessed with this product, i love Charlotte Tilbury so much anf this was definitely not a disappointmentit looks so natural!!!! Definitely will purchase this when im out! Got this product compliments from Influenster

Great!

I love how thin the tip of this pencil is, it shapes the brows well

Great!

Love how gently this glides for my brows! It’s perfect and I love the refillable feature :)

First off I received Brow Cheat (natural brown) for free for testing purposes. To preface, I’m not one to use many brow products, because I come from a family where we have a natural shape and thickness to them. The only thing I do is a wax once every few months or so just to clean them up. That’s it. However, I might just start using them more for special occasions. The brow cheat is awesome. It’s refillable and I absolutely love that. The natural brown is just that—natural. The staying...

New Go To!

The best eyebrow pencil! I had been using the hourglass brow pencil for over 7 years now and this is the one that finally got me to switch! The precision and ability to make tiny strokes is in credible as is the staying power. This has become my new go to.

Just right natural brown brow!

I received this as part of a #complimentary #influenster box and was blown away by the payoff - my brows are now filled in and formed much more neatly. Minimalist make-up is my go to and this fits into my routine wonderfully. Please keep in mind I received this product for free from a sample program and LOVE THIS PRODUCT

Fine blonde natural water resistant

Beautiful color blended seamlessly with my natural brows. Micro fine tip looked super natural against my fine eyebrow hair. Also does not come off/melt off! Perfect for swimming and super humid hot summers. This is my new favorite brow product.

I never got to use the whole thing because the pencil came out. As a formula it was just ok. It was too creamy for my taste. It would look good but if I touched my brows even lightly it would smudge really badly. I would be taking around with a brown streak on my face. This surprised me since I have very dry skin and have never had this happen with any other brow pencil. Even if the pencil didn’t break I don’t think it’s worth the money for this product.

Big brow payoff with minimal effort

Spectacular brow pencil…shocked by the results. I received this as part of a #complimentary #influenster box and was blown away by the payoff - my brows are now filled in but still natural looking. I think makeup experts would have fun playing with the effects but even for a minimalist like me I feel like this is now a must-use product foe everyday. If I was in a rush and could only use two eye products this plus mascara would do it!

Not impressed

Maybe I’m doing it wrong, but everytime I use it the pencil breaks off. I’ve even tried putting out the smallest amount possible and still it breaks. Going back to Anastasia.

Great!

All day wear even in the summer heat. Really liked the shape of the product also. Made it really east to get straight lines and make my job quicker

Just right!

Please keep in mind I received this product for free from a sample program. However, I really did like Thai product. As someone who is constantly on the hunt for the perfect brows this product does just the trick if you are looking for a little bit more fullness without feeling like a comic book character.

Great brow pencil

I have been using the brow pencil for about a week after receiving it through Influenster. It has become a quick favorite over my tried and true Anastasia brow pencil. Fine, natural strokes can easily be created and brushed out into a nice, subtle brow. Really enjoy and will purchase the refills once mine runs out.

Amazing brow pencil

[Employee of sephora] This is a fantastic brow pencil. The sharp point imitates fine hairs without breaking off when you use it. The color is also very pigmented and is long lasting. Definitely worth the investment and I would buy again.

Brow pencil

I love this pencil it works perfectly and u don't have to use a lot of product

smooth application, definitely recommend

I go between using this and the Brow Blade by Urban Decay. For a pencil, I like the accuracy you can get with the tip of the pencil, and getting a more efficient filling effect with the flatter part of the pencil (it’s slanted, like in the photo). The colour was accurate for me; dark brown for CT was equivalent to Dark Drapes by UD. I love the refill option since it’s slightly less waste!

best brow pencil ever

Perfect match and so easy to apply! I have tried so many and this one truly is the best.

Amazing!

I’ve been using Anastasia’s brow wiz for years and decided to change and give this one a try and I don’t regret it! Absolutely worth it!!!

Better Than The Original

This comes with a re-fillable brow pencil section. So much better than the original brow pencil.

Ran through it very quickly

I purchased 2 shades. Both seem way darker when applying them. The swatches are a bit off, but I was able to make Natural Brown work. The application is very smooth and glides very flawlessly. However I find because of this, the formula doesn't do the best job staying put. If you wear it during a hot humid day, it will start to fade. If you touch you eyebrow it will smudge and come off a bit. The tip is the triangular tip which I usually don't like but, this tip is a bit more fine. I find it...

I love the product, however, I’ve gotten two (so it has now happened twice) and they’ve both broken a couple weeks in. I go to use it and the product has disappeared making me believe it breaks very easily. I will not be purchasing a third time… save yourself the money

Great brow pencil, nice tip reminds me of the one on the KVD beauty one but the formula is better it’s like a brow pomade and a twist up pencil had a baby. Super easy to blend because if its creamy consistency, also cheaper in the long run if you just keep buying refills versus $20-$30 brow pencils every time we need a replacement. Only problem with it is that the spoole sucks, I just use one on my brow brush. Great product I went through two and will be buying a refill :)

WASTE OF MONEY

Breaks super easy, not different than any other cheaper brow pencil! DO NOT BUY! Useless waste of money!

I need a back up- this is the most natural(real hair strokes) brow pencil I’ve used. Expensive but worth every penny!

I absolutely loved the consistency and colour of this brow pencil. It goes on well, easily blends it. BUT... When I first opened the pencil, the insert fell out and a majority of the pencil insert shattered on the floor... So i was only left with 25% of product to use. I'll likely be purchasing a refill

good

Pretty good am no make up professional but this pencil is pretty good does its job first time using it and i liked it.

best brow pencil

This was the best brow pencil I've tried. I also like how it's refillable. I definitely buy the refills when I'm out of the original. The pencil has a shape to it that is easy to use. The formula is excellent as well. It's not irritating and it's smooth.

LOVE

Love this little pencil! I usually get taupe and hadn’t realized the light blonde is a better shade match. I love that it blends easily and you can still get that natural brow look! Would def repurchase! Also, I’ve tried other pencils that are too dry. I really like that this pencil is creamier than most but still does a fabulous job. 10/10

I love the way this makes my brows look! I do think I should have gotten a lighter color, but overall I think this is great. Don’t hesitate to buy!

I wanted to like this because it’s refillable but it’s just not the best. The tip is too thick, the product is too creamy. My brows easily look like thick caterpillars than soft and natural. I used a brown shade on my black hair and it still was too dark. Wouldn’t really recommend it for a natural brow look.

great eyebrow pencil!

Love it! Really gives a natural look to my brows. I wish it was a bit thinner, but overall I’m really enjoying it!

After trying this product for a month I can say that i am so happy i never got rid of my MAC Eyebrows Styler Pencil. The Brow Cheat all though it was smooth and certainly gave me the definition that i loved, there is practically no product in the actual pencil which only last 1 month vs the MAC pencil that will last approximately 2-3 months...... Won’t buy this again unfortunately.....

Natural looking

These are easy to use even for a first timer like me. They’re soft and glide on easy. I used tiny strokes to make the eyebrows look fuller yet natural.

nice brow pencil

Definitely a good brow pencil goes on precise and smooth very natural looking , lasts all day !

Quality Product! Would like to see more brow products and with tattoo like staying formula

not worth the money

This is a very thin pencil, great for fine line work or precision outlines. The spoolie is very cheap, like the sample one time use quality. I don’t think this is worth the $, but nothing wrong with the product.

Disappointed

This eyebrow pencil is not very good. Barely made any difference when i used it . A waste of money , Nudestix is much better for the same cost.

Definitely worth trying

I've tried a lot of eyebrow pencils & powders over my many years & I find this one to be the best! I love the thin angled pencil, it's the perfect size to apply in both thiner & thicker brow areas & it wears so well! Wonderful that the easy to use applicator is refillable & it's got a great brush at the other end. The refills are awesome!

For me it's the best!

I've tried a lot of eyebrow pencils & powders over my many years & I find this one to be the best! I love the thin angled pencil, it's the perfect size to apply in both thiner & thicker brow areas & it wears so well! Wonderful that the easy to use applicator is refillable & it's got a great brush at the other end.

Love this brow pencil Matches perfectly, the tip is so precise!

This is one of the best brow pencils I've ever used! Very precise tip and I love that it comes with a spooly on the other end. I love the effect of natural looking hairs it gives.

This pencil worked quite well for me. The shape took a little while to get used to but once you get it down it is an amazing brow pencil. I like that you can do super fine strokes to make your brows look fuller and natural. The color was also great for me. I got soft brown and as long and you don’t press too hard it is perfect! I like the spoolie on the end and my favorite part is that you can buy a refill for it at a much more affordable cost than replacing the whole unit.

I loved this product! The soft brown shade was the perfect match for my brows and the application was so easy. I definitely recommend using this product with the brow fix. It is also super nice that the product is double sided, with one side containing a brush to brush through your eyebrows. Overall very impressed.

Zero Regrets!

Probably the best brow pencil I’ve purchased. I recommend using it with the brow fix and legendary brow from the same brand. Lasts for 12 plus hours and definitely held up after my shower. My brows look bomb!

Buy it

I loved this product! I received it free from influenster for testing and review purposes. It is so easy to apply and glides on so easily. It blends so effortlessly and the color match is amazing!!

Perfect brows in minutes

This pencil is hands down one of the best you will ever buy. I love how natural and full my brows look. Double ended so you can brush through your brows and then fill to create the perfect brow.

ALL IN!

I’ve been converted, and I never want to go back. This will definitely be a repeat for me! I think this is my new favorite product! Works great and fills in where I needed it.

I was so bad at using this when I first got it that my brows looked so bad. Once I learned the technique I was happily surprised. It’s actually easy to use I’m just not that talented!

Amazing!

The precision on this pencil is unmatched! The shade complimented my fair complexion and strawberry blonde hair. I was able to achieve hair like strokes, I love this product!! Long wear! I will purchase again.

Really loved this pencil, BUT I think I could have done a shade darker! It was hard to find a shade because I either have to go too light or too dark bc of my hair color. Otherwise I really liked the pencil, super fine point and precise with the hair like strokes

This pencil works like a crayon, it fills and blends so nicely. Creates a lasting, natural look.

Perfect

Omg, what an excellent product! Easy to use and excellent tight application! Incredible!

I absolutely love this product! It goes on smoothly and it also makes the perfect hair like strokes that I like to do. Having the precision point helps me get a better outcome unlike other brow products.

Amazing!

Amazing product.. I have thin eyebrows so this is a natural looking way to enhance my brows without looking fake. So happy to be able to try this product and will buy it when runs out!

Semi begginer

I am extremely comfortable in doing my makeup but eyebrows are a whole other ballgame. I did minimal at beat. But with product it made it so easy for me to play around and get a natural full look. I still have a lot to learn about shaping but this whole supermodel brow collection is going to become a staple in my makeup routine. I love it and when I don't use it the look feels incomplete.

Average

I’ve been trying this for a few weeks and I’m not that impressed. The formula is waxier than I’m used to so it’s a little harder to blend. The tip is also angled and I prefer smaller tips. This gets bonus points because it’s refillable but aside from that it’s just average.

Super easy to use!

This pencil is super fine, it’s so easy to apply hair like strokes. The color matches my brow color perfectly. I was never much of a person who filled in her brows because it didn’t feel easy. Charlotte Tilbury made it easy. I love this pencil and I can highly recommend it!

Easy to use, makes getting ready fast, color is beautiful and stays on all day.

This product is so easy to use! The way that it's very precise its amazing it definitely deserves the name of brow cheat.

Prepare to be amazed

This is a game changer. I’m a huge fan of Benefit, but I may be changing to this as my go to. My brows looked natural and full. The color went along perfectly with my natural brow color. Highly recommended.

Good Product

I really enjoy this and all of this line of brow products. I really like the fact that it is refillable. It is a bit more waxy than in comparison to my go-to Anistasia brow pencil, but similar in color. I like the thin tip for a natural look.

I really enjoy using this product! It’s super easy to use, great color coverage and long lasting. I have some EXTREMELY blonde eye brow hair and this product is perfect for filling in my sparse looking spots. My eyebrows look beautifully fluffy and full and totally natural. Me but better! The small pencil is easy to use and the spoolie is soft. I’m excited that the pencil is refillable so I can cut down on my single use plastic usage!

I loved the color, and the size of the pencil. It looked very natural and not drawn on. The refillable feature would be really cool, unfortunately, it ended up being a pain. It felt like every time I uncapped the pencil portion it had come unscrewed or the pencil was falling out and I had to put it back togther to be able to use it.

Charlotte does it again!

I have been eyeing this for a while...there are not many CT products that i don’t love. This gives such a beautiful color...i have blonde hair and it’s hard to find a good match and this taupe is perfect! It’s easy to apply and you can buy refills. I have used Anastasia forever, but am now switching. Great product!

Perfect for precise application

My eyebrows lived through the over plucking trend of my teenage years and it shows. I’m also pretty intimidated by using brow pencils because it can go wrong quickly and easily. Because of its shape, this product is perfect for filling in tiny areas in a natural way, and is so soft and buildable that I didn’t feel worried about making a mistake. Though it was soft/natural, it still stayed on all day which was great!

I love how precise the pencil is and how it gives the hair effect without making it look like it was drawn. I love the packaging and it makes me want to choose it instead of the other brow products I have.

I liked this alot. The only thing I didn't like was the formula was kind of stuff and didn't really soften as it warmed up . This color was too light for me but overall worked pretty well. I like the size of this alot

Love this!

I’ve never used eyebrow products before and this was absolutely easy and quick to use! The color was great and I think it really highlighted my eyebrows nicely.

LOVE IT

Okay I'm always skeptical about brow products cause I feel like it takes forever and doesn't do what I want but this Brow pencil is a Game Changer. I absolutely love it. I would totally buy it

Worth it!

I really enjoyed this product. The color was perfect for my brows and I loved the tiny size and the angled shape of the stick. I think that really helped me to create natural looking hair like strokes.

Best eyebrows pencil!

The best eyebrows pencil! Color is buildable, long lasting, and natural looking precision brows. I absolutely LOVE the packaging!

This is such a great brow pencil. You can get such a perfect shape and hair like strokes with the shape of the product. It pairs well with other CT brow products or alone. It’s packaging also feels luxurious like always. It wears well and is long lasting. I definitely recommend!

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Yup I love it!! It's a little darker than my natural but I like it . It's definitely something I will purchase thank you influenster and sephora!!!

It’s just fine.

Honestly this is just an average brow product. It is a bit more waxy than I prefer so I find myself really pushing down on the skin. It lasts well during the day, but so so much less expensive products. I would say the cool part of this is that it is refillable. I would try it if you love the brand but it is not a must have for me.

I think it’s just me.

This pencil may deserve 5 stars but I’ve realized pencil brows are not my forte. Anastasias dip brow is what I use but I love everything Charlotte Tilbury so I had to try this! It’s super soft, just glides on beautifully but I like my brows thick and bold. So it doesn’t do well for thick bold brows but works beautifully for natural brows.

Love it

I always want it a perfect eyebrow pencil and this one is the one! I loveeee this brow cheat pencil, it covers the parts that I want to color, even though that my eyebrows are already full, but I want them to be fully and lightly covered. This is the perfect eyebrow pencil you need. The product is slightly creamy and I love how my eyebrows look. Thanks for Influenster for sending me this box.

Fantastic pencil

I absolutely love this eyebrow pencil! It is so soft and the super skinny tip makes it very easy to be precise with my brows. It takes me almost no time to fill in my brows when I use this pencil. I highly recommend it!

Very satisfied with my new eyebrows pencil!

The Best eyebrows pencil I found on Sephora. I tried most of them . It's easy to apply, great for those with missing eyebrow spots, and has good staying power (I just wish it would be waterproof). Plus I like the fact it has a refill, so you don't need to pay full price again.

Great eyebrow pencil... I have been trying to achieve a more natural brow long and this pencil is very smooth and fills in great

This is super fool proof and easy to use. It did smudge a bit for me, but i loved how easy it was

My new favorite! A product I never knew I needed

I'd never used a brow pencil before but WOW I love this one! It applies so quickly and easy (even for novices like myself) & it doesn't smudge, fade or cake. This particular shade was a bit too dark for me but I could still make it work by using a light hand. The small size of the tip is so perfect and manageable. And the smaller spoolie is also perfect for running through brows dispersing the color perfectly. The best part is that this product is refillable. I don't have words to explain...

great for natural brows!

Amazing for natural, hair-like strokes. I just needed a brow pencil to fill in small gaps here in there in my brows, rather than a product that would basically shape the entirety of my brow. This product was amazing for that as it’s the perfect width, allowing you to create those hair like strokes.

Lifesaver

I love this product!! It is super simple to use which is great for a busy mama like me. I can tell a difference right away when I add to my brows but is still natural looking. Will definitely purchase once I run out.

Goes on smooth and even

I use this brow cheat every day. I like the small tip so I can created hairlike lines but I like you can also use it to fill in your brows as well.

The product itself is pretty good… I like that the tip is small so that it can be more precise. I like that it is refillable. Next time I would probably get natural brown since the taupe is a little too light and looks neutral but looks more warm when it went on.

New Favorite!!

I'll start out by saying that I usually like to alternate between Anastasia brow wiz and Benefit Precisely my brow, depending which one is on sale. So I decided to give this pencil a try because the idea of a refillable pencil that saved money and plastic intrigued me. Well I am happy to say, this is my new favorite and will for sure be replacing my previous favorites!! It glides on so smoothly, the color is rich and beautiful, and it doesn't budge!! One issue I always had with Anastasia is...

Amazing!

I’ve never been a huge brow pencil person until recently. Normally I use the NYX micro brow pencil but when I received this product compliments of Influenster I obviously was going to give it a chance. It’s AMAZING. It’s creamy (but not too creamy) and easy to use and blends amazingly and I just absolutely love it. I definitely recommend this product!

Perfect color!

I adored this product! My brows stayed flawless after 10 hours in the humid US Virgin Islands weather. I would purchase again. I did take off one star because I went through the pencil quickly and the remaining bit crumbled off easily.

Not fine enough for hair like strokes. Also very little product comes in the package! Basically a brow pencil, not worth the $$$

Great Product

I really like this brow pencil, it's a good balance of creamy and waxy so you have great control, I really like the shape and size of it. I also really appreciate that you can buy refills and not have to pay for a whole new pencil when you run out.

Good!

Great Brown Pencil! I liked the Triangle tip and felt it applied easily thin.

Quick and Easy!

I fell in love with the Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat! I am not someone who usually wears makeup but I was intrigued to try this out. It was very easy to apply the pencil and I love that it is refillable. The other end alllwed me to run it thrown my eyebrows for a more realistic look. I would absolutely recommend this product!

I got this free through Influenster. I really like this eyebrow pencil. It's easy to use and the color was perfect

Awesome!

Out of all the Charlotte eyebrow products I have this was probably my favorite! I love the size, it allows me to be pretty precise and I love having this in my purse for it I need to touch up during the day

New Favorite!

I received this as a gift and was pleasantly surprised. I usually like stiffer formulas but this one changed my mind. It’s a bit creamier than ABH or benefit products but it was a seamless blend. I used this to define and the bottom of the brow as well as the tail. I was really surprised that the formula lasted all day because I have oily brows and product wears out fastest for me in that area. I also love this new sustainable direction that CT is moving into I will definitely repurchase the refill.

Breaks easily

I was so excited to get this because of the rave reviews and refillable concept. However, the pencil broke after just 2 uses and also you actually need a refill since there is so little product to be begin with. So the price-point is very high. I also found the texture to be too hard for my needs and while I like a thin tip, this did not give me a natural look (especially on the tail). Will return to Brow Wiz.

This is a very good product for filling in gaps where hair is missing.

In the beginning I really didn't know what I was doing but I started and this brow cheat guided me to shape my brows and make them look full. I love the match of colors to my eyebrows because my hair isn't black

I like to use this on the tail of my eyebrows since the pencil is so thin!

I got a chance to try this beauty thanks to Influenster . It has upped my brow game so much . It could be a little more pigmented but it’s easy to use and helps get those small defined lines . It’s a lot easier to work with than a angled brush and pomade . Will totally be purchasing this in the future

Almost perfect

Love this pencil I would like it a bit darker though but it does a great job

Nice!

I really enjoy using this product. I used to use Anastasia pencil in medium brown as well. I do like how smoothly the product goes on. Packaging is beautiful. I will definitely keep purchasing this product, perhaps in a darker shade. Recommend to anyone who fills in their brows.

I typically use Anastasia eyebrow pencil but since I’ve been wearing this one it’s amazing. The pencil is thin so it makes for a natural eyebrow look. The color fits my eyebrow color perfectly. I’m able to fill in the gaps in my eyebrow very fast. It’s great too for shaping the eyebrow.

Love it so much

I have used a handful of similar micro brow products in the past and this one is my favorite . The pigmentation is perfect where I can control how much color is applied to my brows. It has a tiny tip which helps with the precision and making those little hair like strokes. My eyebrows look great after using this! Definitely a go to!

Breaks easily

I didn’t like this product too much. Maybe two stars is a bit harsh but the pencil broke before I got to use it. Even when you put it back in it moves so it’s hard to be really precise. Also maybe I’m just cheap (which is possible) but I’d expect something better for a product that cost $30+.

LOVEEEEEEE. I love the whole brow line. So easy to use, long lasting. So many shades to choose from.

This is a really great product, goes on really well and easy to use. I took a star off because it’s surprisingly delicate and the head/tip of the pencil fell off a few times, even though I was able to reattach it each time.

Ok

Wish it was a touch creamier but loved the natural finish of this product. Easy to maneuver.

Highly Recommend

This product works great for those who do not have much experience with makeup, it also pairs well with the clear brow gel. If you have light blonde hair I would definitely go for the Taupe shade. It is sleek, nice packaging, and lasts all day. Highly recommend!