Exagger-Eyes Waterproof Eyeshadow Stick

Ridiculously Overpriced

40+$ for one shade is INSANE…PLEASE stop and think about what you are spending money on, especially in this current economy. No makeup is worth this.

Color immediately turns orange

I have cashmere and chestnut sculpt and they both start pretty but within 5 minutes they turn completely orange. I’ve never had this with any other eye shadow. Colour goes completely off

Not bad but not spectacular

Bought 4 of the new eyeshadow sticks because I got suckered into the hype around these. Used ballet quartz 2x only and when I pointed it downwards the whole stick detached from the tube and fell out ;( was never dropped, just randomly broke inside. I'm also finding these sticks don't layer well, the shimmer ones are not as impactful as the FB ones for brand comparisons. They also crease more abit throughout the day. My favourite is the Nude sculpt and Cashmere colors b/c they are very...

Not the best.

[I received this product in exchange for my honest review] For the cost of this product the packaging is horrible and the stuck it self is so flimsy it was broke upon receiving and breaks more with minimal pressure. The formula is decent. The pigment is decent but I have cheaper eye shadow sticks that $1.25 are better product.

never write reviews but I was compelled to after seeing CT’s snooty remarks about drugstore products This sucks! Too soft and breaks. L’Oréal and colorpop perform better and frankly I think youcan get all the shadows in drugstore. Not unique!

Broken after first try

I never write reviews but I was compelled to after seeing CT's snooty remarks about drugstore products This sucks! Too soft and breaks. L'Oréal and colorpop performance better and frankly I think you can get all the shadows in drugstore. Not unique!

Pretty but not long lasting

This shade is perfect for when I want a very natural look, but also I don't want to look too made up (such as, at work). It's barely there, but it's there, if you know what i mean. I feel it also blurs the eyelid a bit, and it looks and applies smoothly. The drawback is that it doesn't last. It doesn't crease on me, but it does disappear from my crease area within 4-5 hours. This is why, while i will use it up, I will not repurchase.

Happy with this purchase

ASTRAL Topaz Absolutely loving this eye shadow stick . I have been using it for lining my bottom lashes and smoking it out and just tight lining my upper eyes ...it works with all my nude shadows or even bolder shades ...Happy with my purchase .😃

Not long lasting

Color is beautiful, but it did not last my 12 hr shift at the hospital. I would say its a 6-8 hr wear. I returned as I expect the product to last at least a day, 8 hr.

Love it. Too expensive. 

It's absolutely way too expensive but as a 50 year-old woman with eyelids, the texture of you know what, this product is amazing and sinks into your skin and blends really well. The longevity is insane. I bought the nude scope and the chestnut sculpt 

Beautiful color and pigment

The pigment on this stick is incredible. Some eyeshadow sticks you really have to rub into your eyelid, this one easily slicks on and is highly pigmented, even a little bit dark honestly I have to blend it out with a brush.

Smooth neutral shadow stick

Beautiful lightweight (not at all cakey), super blendable shadow stick. Great neutral, and stays put. Just bought a second shade because I love this so much.