Select the main image or the expand button to view it full-screen. Swipe left or right on touch devices, or use the arrows, thumbnails, or left and right arrow keys to browse product images.
From the brand
An ultra-clean kôhl eye formula with intense pigments that effortlessly lines, defines, and blends.
TypeeyelinerSize0.01 oz / 0.34 g
Written review conclusions are awaiting a verified full review analysis.
About the product
What it is
An ultra-clean kôhl eye formula with intense pigments that effortlessly lines, defines, and blends.
Highlighted ingredients
Jojoba: Makes the formula glide with ease.- Shea Butter: Provides a smooth application.
Ingredient callouts
This product is vegan, gluten-free, cruelty-free, and comes in recyclable packaging.
What else you need to know
This kôhl formula effortlessly glides intense pigment without skipping—even in the delicate inner eye area. Create any look, from dramatic definition to subtle smoke. The pencil can be sharpened. is a curation of brands committed to evolving the beauty industry. When you see our Clean seal, you can be sure this brand's products are formulated without certain ingredients that are potentially harmful to human health and the environment and also address ingredients clients are concerned about, including phthalates, formaldehyde or formaldehyde releasers, oxybenzone and octinoxate, hydroquinone, triclosan, coal tar, methylisothiazolinone and methylchloroisothiazolinone, insoluble plastic microbeads, and more. For the full list, check out the Ingredients tab. Clean at Sephora is our commitment to offering effective products without certain ingredients, such as parabens, sulfates, phthalates, and mineral oils. Learn more here.
How to Apply
01Glide the sharpened tip along the lash line for skip-free, ultra-pigmented definition.
02Smudge into the lashes for subtle, lived-in definition.
03Blend out using the Eye Shadow I Brush (sold separately) or fingers for a smoky eye effect.
Ingredient Analysis
Full ingredient list
Iron Oxides 77491/77492/77499, Hydrogenated Jojoba Oil, Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil, Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Butyrospermum Parkii (Shea) Butter, Mica 77019, Canola Oil, Copernicia Cerifera (Carnauba) Wax, Glyceryl Caprylate , Euphorbia Cerifera (Candelilla) Wax, Tocopherol, Ascorbyl Palmitate. , , . , , The list of ingredients is subject to change, please consult the packaging of the product purchased.
82 written review excerpts from Sephora, Cult Beauty
KaliKat0002Apr 14, 2024
Perfect for some looks, terrible for others
This liner works well if you're going to blend it out with a brush for a more smokey look. It does NOT work for crisp lines, wings, or any kind of graphic liner because it will smudge. If you use on upper lash line and don't set it with any eyeshadow or powder then it will smudge onto upper eyelid. I use it on my lower lash line only, and blend it out. This is my daily work look and I really love it for this because it is clean, safe, non irritating and stays put all day this way. It is a...
MadamSerpentineSep 21, 2023
Clean Ingredients
[Employee of sephora] There are not a lot of options of eyeliners out there that don't have phenoxyethanol, polyethylene, and ceresin in it. As someone who strives for cleaner makeup options, I'm very happy with this Westman Atelier kohl eyeliner. I hope they come out with more colors!
aysqwMay 23, 2023
Beautiful eyeliner!
I buy every Westman Atelier release because they only launch a few products a year that are meticulously formulated and thought-out in my opinion. This pencil is amazing and goes really well with the Westman aesthetic. I have been devoted to my Victoria Beckham eyeliner in Cocoa for years, but I was excited to try out this new formula. It has a powdery texture instead of a creamy texture like the Victoria Beckham. Because of this, I find it very easy to blend out and it does not smudge on my...
AlexS1000May 19, 2023
Such a great eyeliner!
I loooove this eyeliner! I purchased it the day it came out hoping it would be good. I’m very picky when it comes to eyeliner but I figured hey, westman atelier has such good products, maybe this one is good too. I’m glad I did! This one is precise and easily glides on. It’s not as creamy as the urban decay liners but I find this to be a good thing. It’s light but pigmented - the brown color is sooo pretty. I highly recommend!
nats2VerifiedOct 20, 2024
My favorite liner
I love this, I don’t understand why this gets mediocre reviews. It reminds me of a kohl liner Lancôme used to have years ago and was my holy grail. It’s a lovely texture, easy to use and creates a soft effect that can be blurred as much or as little as you want. Literally my perfect liner. Good staying power on my combo oily lids. I hope they never change the formula
messyclosetOct 19, 2024
I’m 40 and my eyes are starting to look a bit mature. This eyeliner is perfect for my eyes. As I’ve aged I realized that the more pigmented eyeliners don’t suit me anymore and that they tend to age me more. This eyeliner is soft and natural. Very easy to blend but at the same time stays put all day (I do use an eye primer). I feel like my eyes don’t look as tired and heavy when I use this eyeliner vs other eyeliners. If you’re looking for an eyeliner that’s heavier on pigment and offers...
summersweet34May 21, 2023
Eye Love
To begin I have every WA Product & Love every purchase, the Eye Pencil is no Exception. Great shade, glides easily & does not smudge. Not a soft pencil which makes getting a tight line easy to achieve. Gucci continues to make Makeup & skincare easy, glowy & simple. Perfection!
ChicVirtueVerifiedJul 19, 2025
Game changer for me!
I can't understand why there are so few great reviews about this pencil!
1. It goes on super easily.
2. It's really long-lasting.
3. Blends perfectly.
4. It's way better than the gel pencils I used before. This has been a total game changer for me! There's no way I'm going back to gel pencils now.
5. And the MOST important thing is the INGREDIENTS. Has anyone checked the composition? I looked into every ingredient, and it's truly free from chemical additives and doesn't contain any...
AeshajAug 16, 2024
Not for waterline
usage: use it for waterline,
pros: makes my eyes look good,
cons: spread on bottom lid within 5 mins of application & fades away in 5 mins of application.
Is it worth buying : No, not for the price.
westman is a really really good brand but this product is a NO.
CrystalwenwenVerifiedNov 15, 2023
It is not waterproof at all and ended up with a mess in my waterline with only one hour ( my skin is dry)…. Going to return it soon. It is not worth the pricey $$$
CaShOct 24, 2026
Worth the money
Is this silly money to spend on an eye pencil? Yes. Is it the best eye pencil you’ll ever use? Also yes. I was lucky enough to get this beaut in the Cult Beauty Christmas stocking last year (so it was effectively a fraction of the cost). Sadly I am now condemned to future penury as I must use this marvellous pencil forevermore.
BixBeSep 30, 2026
User friendly product
The easiest mascara kohl I’ve ever used. I have the black and brown and they’re both down to nubs. Highly recommend to folks who have struggled with a kohl liner that works and it never irritates my eyes. Sharpens easily and doesn’t break. Holy grail for me now.
