The Overliner Lip Liner Pencil

Love the cherry cola!

I’m not someone who writes reviews much but this lip liner in cherry cola is hands down one of the prettiest colors I’ve ever tried on! It’s absolutely perfect for fall. And the quality is really good. Highly recommend.

runs orange & mid formula

i fear i wasn’t impressed with this formula or shade. this does not hold up to the cool-toned description, it went very orange on me :/ the formula itself gathered very weird on my lip line. i wanted to like this so bad but its a no from me.

NOT ENOUGH PRODUCT FOR THE PRICE. The color is gorgeous but it's too expensive for what you get. I was quite surprised by how much product you get. You get even less product than the MAC lip pencils that everyone raves about. The pencil itself looks quite small when you take it out of the package. It will not change your life and is nothing other than a lip liner. THE PRICE IS CRAZY FOR HOW LITTLE YOU GET.

perfect every day liner

i’m in love with this lip liner. the formula is creamy, yet it’s matte and doesn’t budge. the color is perfect to overline your lips if that’s your vibe. if not, it’s such a natural pouty color, i can see myself wearing it year round!

not worth your money

gorgeous gorgeous color but IMO… NOT WORTH YOUR MONEY!! the lip liner is smaller than my hand and disappears after the first swipe. there are way better lip liners out there that are worth the price!! wanted to love this one but i’m very disappointed by how little the liner is and how little it lasts

Out of Stock…again! Hello Ulta!

Tired of this, and other Sephora items, continually being out of stock. How can a company of this size run out of stock of an item that’s so popular? Think it’s time for me to make the move to Ulta.

Pass on these

I bought Bittersweet and Double Shot and neither shade matches the promo photos. They last about 2 minutes before they fade away. Pass on these.

Not long lasting

Just another pencil liner. Doesn’t last a bit on the lips. Colors are like anything else you’ve seen.

Not right coloring for cool fair skin

Unfortunately not fair skin girl approved. The color ended up being very orange on fair cool skin.

works great!

I chose the shade that MPH calls her favorite (Sizzle), and wow - I truly am impressed. Hilariously, the thing that stands out most about this pencil is that it is neither too soft nor too firm. It's as if the brand found the absolute PERFECT middle point for making a liner that is nice to work with but also wears all day. Personally, i'm not a huge overliner, but I do like to sliiightly overline in order to even out my lips - this product works like a charm for that! Looks natural and...

10/10

Among my top 5 now right along with Chestnut and Cork by MAC and Limitless Brown and Dimensional Dark Brown by MUF. I also love Stone by MAC for a cool toned brown. This is up there with those! Beautiful!

Buy It

Ummm, this is the most amazing lip liner I've ever tried. Other lip liners always end up clinging to the dry patches in the middle of my lips. This one actually made them feel and look moisturized. My only complaint is that it's not cool-toned enough for my ghostly pale, pink skin. PLEASE MAKE TRUE COOL TONES!