Rock ‘N’ Kohl Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil

Relieved this wasn’t discontinued! New formula still doesn’t transfer to my contacts when I tightline upper and lower waterlines <3 I have the old formula in barbella brown and the new in Smokey bronze, the lighter shade is perfect for daytime and summer

smudges!!

looks great when you first put it on, don’t get me wrong- but it does NOT last, by the end of the day i have panda/raccoon eyes… much better options out there, please don’t waste your money!

If I had known the tip would break before I even started using it I don’t think I would have bought this product. When I finally bought a sharpener because I haven’t had to buy one in years , then it broke again never had these issues with NYX EYELINER s

My new holy grail

Since I bought this last spring, I’ve used almost nothing else. This has replaced my previous favourites, the Urban Decay pencils and the Stila twist up ones. I do like a pencil I can sharpen because I like to make a sharp point, and I am amazed at all the reviews complaining about problems with this because I’ve had no issues AR ALL, maybe these people just need new sharpeners. I have had no issues with it smudging thru the day either, altho I usually set it with eyeshadow. It easily lasts...

I’m rating it 2stars just because the color is absolutely beautiful. The pencil on the other hand is horrendous, too soft so it makes a mess when tight lining and is so creamy it clumps. When you try to sharpen it , it keeps breaking. used it for less than 2 months and it is already gone.

New Formula is Terrible

I have worn Charlotte Tilbury from the beginning and have to stop- this new formulation is simply terrible, tip of liner broke as I took it out of box, keeps breaking as I continue to try to sharpen it. Additionally I seemed to have developed an allergy to their shadows and new formulations as all. They're loosing a loyal customer.

Buy Lancome Instead

Zero staying power! It smudges right off. Did they even test it before putting it on the market? horrible formula

Even with primer and setting spray this is all over my eyes by the end of the day. It’s also so dark it may as well be black. Will not repurchase. Stay away.

Hypnotic green is not as shown in picture. It’s not that dark green as shown in here. I would recommend if someone wants to buy please buy instore.

Great color, awful formulation

I used this way longer than I should’ve because of how expensive it was. Always smeared and melted away after 3-4 hours. Kept having to reapply throughout the day. Will never purchase again.

black eyeliner and the smudge applicator 10/10

I love this Charlotte Tilbury pencil! The jet-black pigment is beautiful, and it smudges out incredibly well while still leaving a soft black outline behind. It doesn’t completely lock into place, so you may need to touch it up throughout the day, but that also gives you more time to blend it—even after it begins to dry down. The pointed foam smudger on the other end is phenomenal. It’s especially helpful around the corners of my eyes and along the wing when I’m creating a smoky look. You...

Awful liner

This does not stay on and transferred to my upper eyelid.